Today's church will be out in the snow, cross-country skiing with my parents and my dog. I am way too excited. Today, I got up and shoveled the driveway, which puts me in rarefied company here on Nina Lane. After shoveling, you get the privilege of talking about shoveling for the rest of the day ("ooh, it sure does hurt the wrists to shovel," "my, it's nice to have a shoveled driveway" and so on). Marvin is next to me, barking at the snow faeries, so we're excited to go out and find ourselves some trouble to get into.
I thought I'd comment to you, Lauren, about the "jewishness." I think that catholics have a similar thing; the "catholic identity." It's also why so many Americans claim to be Irish: the "otherness." I hated how O'Reilly liked to say that John Kerry wasn't really a catholic because he's pro-choice, as though catholic identity is some sort of checklist instead of a continuum, or even a grid of cultural and religious affiliation. This grid (four squares, top is high religious identity, bottom is low religious identity; right is high cultural identity, left is low cultural identity) is a useful conceit, but it also doesn't capture the very abstract notion of self-identification.
Anyhow, I think this is a peculiarly American ability - that of choosing your cultural affiliation. Perhaps because of the melting pot (or tossed salad, tee hee), we kind of cling to our otherness. As well, all Americans like to be "working class" or somehow slighted - it's our anti-elitism, and no American wants to be an elitist. So saying that your grandpa didn't go to college, or your great-grandma was from Romania, or whatever it is that makes you special and not elitist, you are salt of the earth. I remember Maureen Dowd suddenly claiming her blue collar status when Barack Obama was running against Hillary; Dowd pointed to some relative and somehow came out as blue collar. This was one week after she used opera as a metaphor. My point is that our disadvantaged creds are carried like medals, perhaps to remind others that we, too, "pulled ourselves up by our bootstraps." My dad's favorite joke, that Bush was born on third and thought he hit a triple, is probably true for most of us middle classers in today's America. We were born into unthinkable material privilege and comfort, but we're also of peasant stock. There is a tension. We're all so damn nouveau riche, treading unsteadily between gloating in our success and reminding ourselves that we're not far from failure.
Bourdieu claimed that we try and use certain forms of capital (say, economic) to trade for others (say, cultural). So a rich businessman will pay a (relatively) poor artist for a painting and both increase their capital - the businessman gets cultural capital, the artist gets economic capital. I think that, in Bourdieu's America, we seem to want to buy a folk capital. The French buy themselves class, the Americans buy themselves street cred.
Marvin is still getting upset at the snow faeries, so we'll go chase them down with my god-skis.
My, how the back does ache after a hard shoveling.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment