Why, yes, EK. As a matter of fact, I do have thoughts. Actually, I made an earlier attempt at blogging a few days ago which was thwarted by small gnomes who cut the internet connection in a failed attempt at world domination. So I lost all my well-crafted thoughts, and you shall have to deal with half-baked ones instead.
First, a brief aside: I was raised Jewish. But much like my fellow cultural Jews, I hold it at arms length. I claim to know almost nothing about the religion and sometimes refer to Jews as though I am not one, thereby pushing it away. Other times I cling onto it in a desperate attempt to "other" myself, letting other people know that I'm not like "them." I'm unique, I'm not mainstream American because I'm not a Protestant (phew). And I don't make carrot-raisin salad for a side dish. I never enslaved your people because I was busy over there counting my money and practicing my blackface. And frequently, I am the self-effacing Jew. (For a better description, watch any movie made by Woody Allen.) Summary: my opinion does not reflect that of many Jews.
So, while I am certainly not a pro-zionist, I would also not call myself an anti-zionist either. I hesitate to say that the idea of a Jewish state is bad... assuming that a Jewish state refers to our emphasis on social equality and justice, intellectualism, and damn good food. However, poor execution, Israel. Jews have always been marginalized, whether we do it to ourselves or we become society's scapegoat. Historically, we have suffered many systematic oppressions and yet we persevere as a (culturally shifting) group. It is our memory, the Jewish collective consciousness, that holds us together as a people. (Read Everything is Illuminated by Jonathan Safran Foer or see the movie with Elijah Wood.) While some people perceive "Jewish" as an ethnicity, it is only a culture that can pass along memory. To me, the consideration that our diasporic culture could need to reclaim a physical space is incomprehensible. Let the Wailing Wall be a place of pilgrimage, but let it be so for everyone.
However, it would be wrong to deny that, as an historically oppressed peoples, we do not need a safe space. (We should probably question why "space" is inherently unsafe.) To call it a "return/reclaiming of the holy land"? Why even bother. Liberal Jews (probably excluding Israelis) acknowledge that the conquest of Israel/Palestine is an expression of symbolic capital: Jews are expressing their strength, mainly in military and wealth. If Jews are so socially-oriented, how can we let this happen?
Summary: Not pro-zion, but not anti-zion, per se. California is, after all, a state of mind, right?
In other news, I've been stuck in heavy snowfall for the past 4 days. After extensive travels to places far warmer than the Northeast, I vowed that I would never use a snowshovel again. Well, I failed. But the repetetive motion got me thinking about seasons, changing of seasons, and how we connect with the world according to how we experience changing seasons. Animistic religions saw something greater in the prescence or absence of the sun or rain. They connected with it, prayed for it, loved it, feared it...Which led to thoughts on spirituality. Which I dig. Even though I am pretty sure I have yet to find a religion that suits me, I have a connection with something greater (I think). Being outside, being in a place where I can re-connect with the earth, with natural processes, helps me reconnect with myself. Nature is my favorite temple. It's scary and illusive. It's wonderous and massive. It's endless (despite our constant attempts at splitting it up, breaking it down). It's predictable and totally not. It is amazing and awesome. It's what I need, more than any visit to church. And since I'm stranded this week, no church. Just outside time.
Saturday, December 20, 2008
Thursday, December 18, 2008
Countdown to Hanukkah 2008!!
As the non-Jewish contributor to this blog, I decided to devote a little time to Hanukkah ... a holiday I have never celebrated and until this moment did not know how to spell. I found this website that provides very useful information for the neophytes among us. For one thing, I learned that Hanukkah is not all that important to Jews - not as important as the many other Jewish holidays of which I no nothing.
Also, I learned that the Maccabees were bad-ass Jews whose name comes from the Hebrew word for "Hammer." Apparently, the Greeks were defiling the Holy Temple in Jerusalem (offering pigs for sacrifice to multiple gods) and the Jews fought back. All this was about 165 BCE. When the Jews got their temple back, there was a miracle at the temple: candles remained lit for eight days on oil that was only supposed to last for a day! If you are underwhelmed by this miracle, you are not Jewish.
That is my Jewish lesson for the day.
As for personal opinions on Jewishness, I have very few. I was once afraid that I'd insulted Lauren because I said something anti-Israel, but I later found out she's anti-Israel, too. One of my problems with Israel (besides the whole geopolitical thing) is that the young men get out of the military, no doubt a hard, dangerous military (not the namby pamby military of, say, the Swiss), go to foreign lands (especially India and Thailand) and do as many drugs as possible. This creates a good deal of tension, as you may well imagine. Some Israeli who is used to carrying around an automatic weapon and having people fear him comes to a poor country, yells at people a lot, wears tie-dye and velvet pants, and takes ecstasy every day. The former-military-turned-insta-hippie is a poor representative of Israel. I think there should be a prolonged de-programming after the military, and it should involve frequent reminders that bongo drums are not toys and LSD is a superfluous drug in a country that deifies cows.
Actually, I think I can summon a bit of an opinion about Jews in general. I am jealous of the culture, the ability of a people to maintain their identity over centuries while also adapting to the economic and social realities that they find themselves in. That is, truly, a miracle. What other religious group has survived so long - maybe Zoroastrians? At any rate, it may take a religion to keep people glued like this for such a long time. Any thoughts, Lauren?
Also, I learned that the Maccabees were bad-ass Jews whose name comes from the Hebrew word for "Hammer." Apparently, the Greeks were defiling the Holy Temple in Jerusalem (offering pigs for sacrifice to multiple gods) and the Jews fought back. All this was about 165 BCE. When the Jews got their temple back, there was a miracle at the temple: candles remained lit for eight days on oil that was only supposed to last for a day! If you are underwhelmed by this miracle, you are not Jewish.
That is my Jewish lesson for the day.
As for personal opinions on Jewishness, I have very few. I was once afraid that I'd insulted Lauren because I said something anti-Israel, but I later found out she's anti-Israel, too. One of my problems with Israel (besides the whole geopolitical thing) is that the young men get out of the military, no doubt a hard, dangerous military (not the namby pamby military of, say, the Swiss), go to foreign lands (especially India and Thailand) and do as many drugs as possible. This creates a good deal of tension, as you may well imagine. Some Israeli who is used to carrying around an automatic weapon and having people fear him comes to a poor country, yells at people a lot, wears tie-dye and velvet pants, and takes ecstasy every day. The former-military-turned-insta-hippie is a poor representative of Israel. I think there should be a prolonged de-programming after the military, and it should involve frequent reminders that bongo drums are not toys and LSD is a superfluous drug in a country that deifies cows.
Actually, I think I can summon a bit of an opinion about Jews in general. I am jealous of the culture, the ability of a people to maintain their identity over centuries while also adapting to the economic and social realities that they find themselves in. That is, truly, a miracle. What other religious group has survived so long - maybe Zoroastrians? At any rate, it may take a religion to keep people glued like this for such a long time. Any thoughts, Lauren?
Tuesday, December 16, 2008
Gays. That's right. I'm going to rant.
Now we've finally set up two separate accounts so that we can tell each other apart. Hopefully this shows up as written by "EK."
We didn't go to church this week, though we both went hiking in some old growth spruce forest in the Oregon coast range. That's pretty close. We had every intention of going to the Kingdom Hall (Jehovah's Witnesses), but then a long, slow breakfast interfered. F- it.
Lauren and I both got these incredibly nice cards from the Pentecostals, thanking us for going to their service. I think that they have the best service I've been to so far, in terms of how I felt afterward. I'd like to go again. Maybe I will.
I'm currently listening to a This American Life radio program called "Heretics" about a man who stops believing in hell and starts believing that everyone gets to go to Heaven (even gays). It's got me thinking about gays, and now I'm going to expound a bit. This is called procrastination.
Since Measure 9 in Oregon (1993), I have thought of myself as pro-gay. Not ambivalent, or somehow not anti-gay, but pro-gay. I'm convinced it's the civil rights issue of this generation. I guess it takes your first taste of overt hatred to make you angry enough to embrace people you don't even know. I didn't know any gay people then; well, I didn't know I knew any gay people then. Some people in my high school who were (apparently) in a government class, put up a poster in the hallway that said "Burn Fags not Flags" to support Measure 9. It was taken down, but not quickly enough to avoid a small spontaneous pro-Measure 9 cheering squad, consisting of (I can only assume) the most flaming, self-loathing, closeted gays in my high school.
This will be my preaching for the day. Here we go. I'm going to take the stupidest arguments against gays and give you (um, whoever you are) my spin. Why? Because this is my goddamn blog.
1) Gays should "just be quiet."
First, this assumes straights are "quiet" about their sex lives. Everyone gets treated to non-stop hetero exposure. It's leaking out of crappy magazines (Cosmopolitan), crappier TV shows (all of them), and even on Christian websites. Why don't those straights stop walking around, holding hands and kissing and rubbing my face in their straightness?
Another angle on this argument could be that if gays would just shut up about their orientation, there would be no prejudice against it. This is the "I could care less" argument, one that I hear frequently invoked by right-wing radio hosts, who seem to also be the only non-racists in the world - so much so, they don't even see race! This is the closest corollary I see to the civil rights movements of the 1960s, when blacks were told to just be quiet because they were stirring up all kinds of uncomfortable feelings among nice white people who didn't even think of themselves as racists. But the acts of violence against blacks, though carried out by few whites, were symbolic of a much larger system of inequity. Of course the whites couldn't see the inequity; it wasn't part of the fabric of their lives, it didn't shape their interactions. Read Du Bois (Souls of Black Folk) for a much more well-written argument of this vein. If you (and I don't mean you, but you over there) don't think there's discrimination against gay people, what planet are you from? Seriously. Mars?
2) Gay sex is "gross"
Um, sex between most people is gross. Unless you're Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt, I don't want to ever imagine sex between anyone. If this argument was valid, then almost everyone would need to stop having sex.
3) Sex is for procreation
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha! No really. Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha.
4) Gays are condemned in the bible
I know we've all heard the arguments against this, but I'd like to underline a few. Leviticus 18:22 does, indeed, say: Thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with womankind: it is abomination" (KJV). Clear enough. Leviticus, let us remember, also prohibits sex with a menstruating woman (this speaks to #3 - we're on it) and the kosher laws, which also prohibit wearing clothing of two textiles (damn those poly blends!).
But let's just stick with the notion that the bible condemns homosexuality (Romans I, say). Alright. What else you got? This was a stopping point for an evangelical in North Carolina who used to follow me around when I was a waitress. He was the restaurant manager, sweet as could be, and he really wanted to save my soul.
Him: Don't you believe in the bible?
Me: No.
Him: But the bible says that if you don't believe in it, you'll go to hell.
Nice argument. Try and work your way out of that chinese finger trap. Here's what I've gleaned from the bible: Jesus was incredibly loving and accepting. The god of the old testament was a jerk. I guess this aligns me (somewhat) with my superficial reading of the Baha'i faith: prophets come to correct our misinterpretations. So if we take our first lesson, that Jesus was incredibly loving and accepting, then I think we can safely say that he wouldn't have sided with the assholes who currently promulgate his faith. Sorry for the offense. I'm not feeling charitable today.
Finally, I can accept that this is a Christian nation. I believe it is one, in fact. Demographic evidence bears this out. I'm not going to belabor the separation of church and state here, either. But I think it is perfectly acceptable to be a Christian nation, one where most people are Christian, and not interfere with others' right to marry the person (or people!) of their choice. It really won't hurt you. If god hates it that much, then he'll sort it out. I like to think (in my reading of the bible) that god gives gays a special street in Heaven, where the houses are all nicely kept and broadway music streams out from every corner.
5) "I'm not against gays, I'm against gay marriage"
Well, I'm against your marriage then. Marriages have evolved, obviously. And scholars have written eloquently on the topic, so I'll save my breath. Marriages, as a cultural contract, have very little to do with sanctity and everything to do with legal arrangements. A friend in Portland had to go through a million hoops to get all the rights in his relationship (with his partner of 13 years) that a straight couple would get from a two-minute ceremony with Elvis.
If your marriage is undermined by a gay couple's marriage, then your marriage is a fraud.
6) Gays choose to be that way, so ...
Okay, let's just get past all the contradictions this raises, like when I chose to be straight (I believe I was 6). Let's say that gays did choose to be gay. Against all evidence and rationality, gays choose to be gay. So what? That means that they don't deserve the same rights as others? I'm sorry, Mr. Foot Fetish, but I think that your lifestyle, the way you like to carry out your sex life, disqualifies you from equal status in this culture. Or, Mr. Foot Fetish, you can have that foot fetish, but only if it results in babies.
That is all I can muster on this topic. I have wasted enough time. I need to do some actual work now. This actually has very little to do with religion, since I think that most religions can create a space for all people.
But for those unconverted, here are some sinners.
We didn't go to church this week, though we both went hiking in some old growth spruce forest in the Oregon coast range. That's pretty close. We had every intention of going to the Kingdom Hall (Jehovah's Witnesses), but then a long, slow breakfast interfered. F- it.
Lauren and I both got these incredibly nice cards from the Pentecostals, thanking us for going to their service. I think that they have the best service I've been to so far, in terms of how I felt afterward. I'd like to go again. Maybe I will.
I'm currently listening to a This American Life radio program called "Heretics" about a man who stops believing in hell and starts believing that everyone gets to go to Heaven (even gays). It's got me thinking about gays, and now I'm going to expound a bit. This is called procrastination.
Since Measure 9 in Oregon (1993), I have thought of myself as pro-gay. Not ambivalent, or somehow not anti-gay, but pro-gay. I'm convinced it's the civil rights issue of this generation. I guess it takes your first taste of overt hatred to make you angry enough to embrace people you don't even know. I didn't know any gay people then; well, I didn't know I knew any gay people then. Some people in my high school who were (apparently) in a government class, put up a poster in the hallway that said "Burn Fags not Flags" to support Measure 9. It was taken down, but not quickly enough to avoid a small spontaneous pro-Measure 9 cheering squad, consisting of (I can only assume) the most flaming, self-loathing, closeted gays in my high school.
This will be my preaching for the day. Here we go. I'm going to take the stupidest arguments against gays and give you (um, whoever you are) my spin. Why? Because this is my goddamn blog.
1) Gays should "just be quiet."
First, this assumes straights are "quiet" about their sex lives. Everyone gets treated to non-stop hetero exposure. It's leaking out of crappy magazines (Cosmopolitan), crappier TV shows (all of them), and even on Christian websites. Why don't those straights stop walking around, holding hands and kissing and rubbing my face in their straightness?
Another angle on this argument could be that if gays would just shut up about their orientation, there would be no prejudice against it. This is the "I could care less" argument, one that I hear frequently invoked by right-wing radio hosts, who seem to also be the only non-racists in the world - so much so, they don't even see race! This is the closest corollary I see to the civil rights movements of the 1960s, when blacks were told to just be quiet because they were stirring up all kinds of uncomfortable feelings among nice white people who didn't even think of themselves as racists. But the acts of violence against blacks, though carried out by few whites, were symbolic of a much larger system of inequity. Of course the whites couldn't see the inequity; it wasn't part of the fabric of their lives, it didn't shape their interactions. Read Du Bois (Souls of Black Folk) for a much more well-written argument of this vein. If you (and I don't mean you, but you over there) don't think there's discrimination against gay people, what planet are you from? Seriously. Mars?
2) Gay sex is "gross"
Um, sex between most people is gross. Unless you're Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt, I don't want to ever imagine sex between anyone. If this argument was valid, then almost everyone would need to stop having sex.
3) Sex is for procreation
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha! No really. Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha.
4) Gays are condemned in the bible
I know we've all heard the arguments against this, but I'd like to underline a few. Leviticus 18:22 does, indeed, say: Thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with womankind: it is abomination" (KJV). Clear enough. Leviticus, let us remember, also prohibits sex with a menstruating woman (this speaks to #3 - we're on it) and the kosher laws, which also prohibit wearing clothing of two textiles (damn those poly blends!).
But let's just stick with the notion that the bible condemns homosexuality (Romans I, say). Alright. What else you got? This was a stopping point for an evangelical in North Carolina who used to follow me around when I was a waitress. He was the restaurant manager, sweet as could be, and he really wanted to save my soul.
Him: Don't you believe in the bible?
Me: No.
Him: But the bible says that if you don't believe in it, you'll go to hell.
Nice argument. Try and work your way out of that chinese finger trap. Here's what I've gleaned from the bible: Jesus was incredibly loving and accepting. The god of the old testament was a jerk. I guess this aligns me (somewhat) with my superficial reading of the Baha'i faith: prophets come to correct our misinterpretations. So if we take our first lesson, that Jesus was incredibly loving and accepting, then I think we can safely say that he wouldn't have sided with the assholes who currently promulgate his faith. Sorry for the offense. I'm not feeling charitable today.
Finally, I can accept that this is a Christian nation. I believe it is one, in fact. Demographic evidence bears this out. I'm not going to belabor the separation of church and state here, either. But I think it is perfectly acceptable to be a Christian nation, one where most people are Christian, and not interfere with others' right to marry the person (or people!) of their choice. It really won't hurt you. If god hates it that much, then he'll sort it out. I like to think (in my reading of the bible) that god gives gays a special street in Heaven, where the houses are all nicely kept and broadway music streams out from every corner.
5) "I'm not against gays, I'm against gay marriage"
Well, I'm against your marriage then. Marriages have evolved, obviously. And scholars have written eloquently on the topic, so I'll save my breath. Marriages, as a cultural contract, have very little to do with sanctity and everything to do with legal arrangements. A friend in Portland had to go through a million hoops to get all the rights in his relationship (with his partner of 13 years) that a straight couple would get from a two-minute ceremony with Elvis.
If your marriage is undermined by a gay couple's marriage, then your marriage is a fraud.
6) Gays choose to be that way, so ...
Okay, let's just get past all the contradictions this raises, like when I chose to be straight (I believe I was 6). Let's say that gays did choose to be gay. Against all evidence and rationality, gays choose to be gay. So what? That means that they don't deserve the same rights as others? I'm sorry, Mr. Foot Fetish, but I think that your lifestyle, the way you like to carry out your sex life, disqualifies you from equal status in this culture. Or, Mr. Foot Fetish, you can have that foot fetish, but only if it results in babies.
That is all I can muster on this topic. I have wasted enough time. I need to do some actual work now. This actually has very little to do with religion, since I think that most religions can create a space for all people.
But for those unconverted, here are some sinners.
Thursday, December 11, 2008
Devotional, Baha'i-style
I've had a few days to marinate on my Baha'i experience. We met with two Baha'i ladies on Monday and on Tuesday we sat in on a Baha'i devotional. Today is Thursday and I realize how difficult it is to not write almost immediately after the experience. But I will try to piece together my thoughts, mainly for my sake.
Monday: Walking to the coffee shop with Erin, we exchanged our excitement about what we would learn. I mostly knew about the Baha'i's emphasis on volunteerism/support for and recognition of humanity and humanity through education. Erin and I also talked briefly about how the Baha'i's recognize that there is a prophet that is right for each moment in time. So, armed with a brief knowledge of the religion, I think I all too quickly became disillusioned once we started learning a bit about Baha'i.
Number one. The idea that we were created in God's image. God is our creator, and just like a table that was crafted by a carpenter can never Truly know the carpenter, we can never know God. I agree that we can never "know" the universe or fully comprehend our existence. But throw the word "God" in there, and my mind just goes into screensaver mode. I don't know what it is about formulating our existence around God, but I can never actually talk about this. This I found especially weird because the Baha'i believe that science and religion are not incompatible. I can look in at the fundamentalist Christians with a more compassionate eye because they are trapped in God mode and science works on a totally different level. But how can we talk about God (and creation) AND science (ie. evolution)? This blows my mind. We can talk spirituality, essence of life, and etc.; let's avoid God-talk, particularly in the realm of science.
B. So you have Baha'u'allah, the prophet. You have his son, who interpreted his writings, and you have his grandson, who also interpreted his writings. Now there is an elected council of 9 (Very significant number throughout the world. Awesome.) that deliberates on various Baha'i issues and etc. How is this somehow more pure or sacred or less likely to dilute the religion? I don't know how this can possibly maintain a unified Baha'i religious following in the future. People will always interpret and re-interpret writings. Is it truly possible for a council to mediate this somehow?
Number three-a bit of a nit-picky point of contention. I might be the rain on your parade (or a Debbie downer) but Israel is located in a desert. This means that it does not rain a whole heck of a lot. This means that there should not be green grass in the desert year-round. Yes, your administrative center and the shrine of the Bab is located in Haifa, in a desert. Much like a green golf course in the middle of the Arizona desert, this is the symbol of man's power OVER the environment, emphasizing our difference from nature. While the gardens are beautiful and a central pilgrimage point for Baha'i, the environmentalist in me (not to mention my spiritual side) cries to see over-watered grasses in the desert.
Now, getting to Tuesday's devotional...
It was beautiful. Baha'u'allah's words are beautiful. It was an intimate, Quaker-style gathering in a small apartment. We read prayers by candlelight ("We" actually being the Baha'i who were of average age 15 years) and sang songs spontaneously. It was organic. It was the most organic service of my life. There were some people with beautiful voices, and Erin and I were even able to sing some of the songs (because of the repetition). The one off-putting thing (that I've blogged about before) is the whole referring to God as "He." How can we even begin to talk about equality and justice when the creator is a man? Erin and I had also discussed taking Baha'i classes because it sounded really interesting to learn more about the faith and Baha'u'allah, but once I saw the workbooks I had flashbacks to years and years of Hebrew school and knew immediately that it is not for me.
A couple of interesting things: My dad lived in India for a while when I was growing up and I remember getting postcards of Delhi's Baha'i lotus temple, but I never connected the two until Monday. Also, I have lately been on a quest of love. Since a major part of my life has fallen apart two years ago, I've been working on this unconditional love thing: unconditional love of friends, family, and even people that I wouldn't normally like. By loving people for who they are (their good heart and spirit) instead of what they do I hope that I can re-build that aspect of my life. So the connection here is that the Baha'i are really into love (unconditional love) for humanity and people. So I really found that aspect of the religion to be attractive and meaningful. I'll probably read more about the Baha'i in the future.
Monday: Walking to the coffee shop with Erin, we exchanged our excitement about what we would learn. I mostly knew about the Baha'i's emphasis on volunteerism/support for and recognition of humanity and humanity through education. Erin and I also talked briefly about how the Baha'i's recognize that there is a prophet that is right for each moment in time. So, armed with a brief knowledge of the religion, I think I all too quickly became disillusioned once we started learning a bit about Baha'i.
Number one. The idea that we were created in God's image. God is our creator, and just like a table that was crafted by a carpenter can never Truly know the carpenter, we can never know God. I agree that we can never "know" the universe or fully comprehend our existence. But throw the word "God" in there, and my mind just goes into screensaver mode. I don't know what it is about formulating our existence around God, but I can never actually talk about this. This I found especially weird because the Baha'i believe that science and religion are not incompatible. I can look in at the fundamentalist Christians with a more compassionate eye because they are trapped in God mode and science works on a totally different level. But how can we talk about God (and creation) AND science (ie. evolution)? This blows my mind. We can talk spirituality, essence of life, and etc.; let's avoid God-talk, particularly in the realm of science.
B. So you have Baha'u'allah, the prophet. You have his son, who interpreted his writings, and you have his grandson, who also interpreted his writings. Now there is an elected council of 9 (Very significant number throughout the world. Awesome.) that deliberates on various Baha'i issues and etc. How is this somehow more pure or sacred or less likely to dilute the religion? I don't know how this can possibly maintain a unified Baha'i religious following in the future. People will always interpret and re-interpret writings. Is it truly possible for a council to mediate this somehow?
Number three-a bit of a nit-picky point of contention. I might be the rain on your parade (or a Debbie downer) but Israel is located in a desert. This means that it does not rain a whole heck of a lot. This means that there should not be green grass in the desert year-round. Yes, your administrative center and the shrine of the Bab is located in Haifa, in a desert. Much like a green golf course in the middle of the Arizona desert, this is the symbol of man's power OVER the environment, emphasizing our difference from nature. While the gardens are beautiful and a central pilgrimage point for Baha'i, the environmentalist in me (not to mention my spiritual side) cries to see over-watered grasses in the desert.
Now, getting to Tuesday's devotional...
It was beautiful. Baha'u'allah's words are beautiful. It was an intimate, Quaker-style gathering in a small apartment. We read prayers by candlelight ("We" actually being the Baha'i who were of average age 15 years) and sang songs spontaneously. It was organic. It was the most organic service of my life. There were some people with beautiful voices, and Erin and I were even able to sing some of the songs (because of the repetition). The one off-putting thing (that I've blogged about before) is the whole referring to God as "He." How can we even begin to talk about equality and justice when the creator is a man? Erin and I had also discussed taking Baha'i classes because it sounded really interesting to learn more about the faith and Baha'u'allah, but once I saw the workbooks I had flashbacks to years and years of Hebrew school and knew immediately that it is not for me.
A couple of interesting things: My dad lived in India for a while when I was growing up and I remember getting postcards of Delhi's Baha'i lotus temple, but I never connected the two until Monday. Also, I have lately been on a quest of love. Since a major part of my life has fallen apart two years ago, I've been working on this unconditional love thing: unconditional love of friends, family, and even people that I wouldn't normally like. By loving people for who they are (their good heart and spirit) instead of what they do I hope that I can re-build that aspect of my life. So the connection here is that the Baha'i are really into love (unconditional love) for humanity and people. So I really found that aspect of the religion to be attractive and meaningful. I'll probably read more about the Baha'i in the future.
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
Baha'u'llah and his merry band of Peacesters
We met with the Baha'i ladies yesterday and it's been messing with my brain ever since. I like what they say about society: prophets come at a particular time and place to guide people; as humans we don't find absolute truth but its reflection; the purpose of religion (and life) is to find unity in our humanity. This is all verygood, veryverygood. I get hung up on some of the fundamentals: God is absolute and all-knowing (and so on - they derive many of these ideas from Islam); Humans have eternal souls; Baha'u'llah is the "promised one" of this age. I was reading a Baha'i pamphlet last night and some of the words of Baha'u'llah are compelling, but some just sound like the same old BS, and if Baha'is become the dominant world religion, I fear they'll be just like the others. Examples below.
Compelling: Baha'is say people reject prophets because they want the prophets to affirm what they already believe. So people think that when Jesus comes back, he'll reward them (and their fellow believers in truth) and punish everyone else. But prophets do not return to tell people what they already know/think. They come and are persecuted and rejected by the powerful (who, today, all think that Jesus would reward them).
Maybe not so much: Mankind has been progressing through various spiritual stages. Progressivism is repugnant to me; why would a faith that values all previous prophets also claim progression? Baha'is are explicitly monotheistic, and the assumed animistic - polytheistic - monotheistic progression is unconvincing. It raises a question: as we progress materially, do we progress spiritually?
Blah: Mankind is ready for one, unified faith. This is where I could see Baha'is becoming just another religion. I mean, everybody thinks that their faith will "unite" mankind, so long as all mankind adopts their faith. I know that Baha'is have been persecuted horribly in Iran - but incipient faiths always start from the bottom (see "prophets" above) and become more and more rigid and self-righteous as they gain power.
We're going to a devotional tonight, and I'm looking forward to it. I want to keep my mind open to this religion, for whatever reason. I like the ideas behind Baha'ism, I just don't know whether I can accept the tenets. Also, everyone I've met who's a Baha'i is thoughtful and educated. But so were the Rajneeshees. (I do not mean to seriously compare the two. But I do remember lots of people in The Dalles commenting on how "educated" the Rajneeshees were).
Compelling: Baha'is say people reject prophets because they want the prophets to affirm what they already believe. So people think that when Jesus comes back, he'll reward them (and their fellow believers in truth) and punish everyone else. But prophets do not return to tell people what they already know/think. They come and are persecuted and rejected by the powerful (who, today, all think that Jesus would reward them).
Maybe not so much: Mankind has been progressing through various spiritual stages. Progressivism is repugnant to me; why would a faith that values all previous prophets also claim progression? Baha'is are explicitly monotheistic, and the assumed animistic - polytheistic - monotheistic progression is unconvincing. It raises a question: as we progress materially, do we progress spiritually?
Blah: Mankind is ready for one, unified faith. This is where I could see Baha'is becoming just another religion. I mean, everybody thinks that their faith will "unite" mankind, so long as all mankind adopts their faith. I know that Baha'is have been persecuted horribly in Iran - but incipient faiths always start from the bottom (see "prophets" above) and become more and more rigid and self-righteous as they gain power.
We're going to a devotional tonight, and I'm looking forward to it. I want to keep my mind open to this religion, for whatever reason. I like the ideas behind Baha'ism, I just don't know whether I can accept the tenets. Also, everyone I've met who's a Baha'i is thoughtful and educated. But so were the Rajneeshees. (I do not mean to seriously compare the two. But I do remember lots of people in The Dalles commenting on how "educated" the Rajneeshees were).
Sunday, December 7, 2008
Glossolalia.
That's right. Glossolalia. The act of speaking in tongue(s). I knew that this is what Pentecostals do, but I had no idea what we were in for earlier this evening.
After a night of sin (re: moderate to heavy drinking), Erin and I were saddened to realize there was no way we could make it to church in the morning to repent. Praise Jesus that the Pentecostals offer both morning AND evening services. So we went to evening service. The usual church goers (which includes your less-than-usual church goers) were waiting patiently for the service to start. We met some nice folks who explained that there would be a baptism at the end of the service, if we wanted to stick around. I will get to that later. First, the service commenced with a prayer, which, as Erin said below, started like a usual prayer. This lasted for all of half a second and then a lot of people started speaking in tongue. It totally caught me off-guard and it took me a few minutes to recover. This was no Mormon service. But I got used to it, and found myself saying "Amen," and "Allelujah" when the rest of the congregation did. The power of the masses is amazing.
And the singing. I haven't sung like that since I drove cross country by myself. It was wonderful and releasing. No one was judging me. It was beautiful. I loved watching everyone get really into it, especially the bigger woman shaking the tambourine shaped like the fish. After about 20 minutes of singing praise songs, we were encouraged to get up and shake everyone's hand. This was really enjoyable and I got a wonderful huge from said Tambourine lady. I felt loved.
After a beautiful sermon from the pastor about our human sin, we watched two baptisms. There was a woman (maybe in her 30s) and a young man (maybe in his late teens) one the baptismal order for the evening. The woman was definitely "filled with the Holy Ghost" and I was very excited that she found God.
Besides the positively energizing spirit that I felt while at this church, I also noticed that maybe church service would be a problem if there was ever... say... a power outage. It is strange seeing so many modern instruments being used at a worship service. But then again, Jewish Sabbath is like a time-warp into pre-electricity days.
Tomorrow we meet with young Baha'i believers (What do they call themselves?). Our adventures continue.
After a night of sin (re: moderate to heavy drinking), Erin and I were saddened to realize there was no way we could make it to church in the morning to repent. Praise Jesus that the Pentecostals offer both morning AND evening services. So we went to evening service. The usual church goers (which includes your less-than-usual church goers) were waiting patiently for the service to start. We met some nice folks who explained that there would be a baptism at the end of the service, if we wanted to stick around. I will get to that later. First, the service commenced with a prayer, which, as Erin said below, started like a usual prayer. This lasted for all of half a second and then a lot of people started speaking in tongue. It totally caught me off-guard and it took me a few minutes to recover. This was no Mormon service. But I got used to it, and found myself saying "Amen," and "Allelujah" when the rest of the congregation did. The power of the masses is amazing.
And the singing. I haven't sung like that since I drove cross country by myself. It was wonderful and releasing. No one was judging me. It was beautiful. I loved watching everyone get really into it, especially the bigger woman shaking the tambourine shaped like the fish. After about 20 minutes of singing praise songs, we were encouraged to get up and shake everyone's hand. This was really enjoyable and I got a wonderful huge from said Tambourine lady. I felt loved.
After a beautiful sermon from the pastor about our human sin, we watched two baptisms. There was a woman (maybe in her 30s) and a young man (maybe in his late teens) one the baptismal order for the evening. The woman was definitely "filled with the Holy Ghost" and I was very excited that she found God.
Besides the positively energizing spirit that I felt while at this church, I also noticed that maybe church service would be a problem if there was ever... say... a power outage. It is strange seeing so many modern instruments being used at a worship service. But then again, Jewish Sabbath is like a time-warp into pre-electricity days.
Tomorrow we meet with young Baha'i believers (What do they call themselves?). Our adventures continue.
HALLELUJAH! PRAISE JEEZUS!
Pentecostals are awesome. I can say that without any irony. Lauren (or Rolen, as I like to call her) and I went to the evening service at a little brick church, very cozy and warm, with around 25 people. We were recognized as "visitors" and given forms to fill out. I like to think we're sort of like aliens - people just look at us and are like, "you're not of our kind. But you are welcome to join us; we are very tolerant of space people."
The first prayer was the hardest of the evening. The pastor's helper got up and said we're going to pray, and Lauren and I both put our heads down and suddenly everyone else has their hands up and they're saying, or yelling, or muttering "la la la HALLELUJAH! See la la ob la" and Lauren and I looked at each other and that was it for the next 30 seconds or so. I tried so damn hard not to laugh, but I guess the holy spirit was telling me to do it. So I laughed. Then we sang, loudly, along with a pianist, a drummer, and a woman with a great voice and a microphone. Lauren and I clapped, sang, yelled out hallelujah in between the songs ... They are really into repetition (the better to sing to) and I sang as loudly as I have ever sang without the aid of alcohol. It was wonderful, I felt good. I can still hear the songs in my head, over and over. The whole experience was holistic: the songs, the way people were so sincere, the smell of smoke lingering on some of the other participants.
Which brings me to other people in the church. They were diverse. Some looked like headbangers, and then there was the nice Christian family, with the girls in long skirts with long hair, and there were lovely old ladies who gave us hugs. Two people got baptized, one a young woman who would not have looked out of place at the Peacock, who said a prayer "for the father of my children, that he can find God" but she was with some other dude there, with long hair and dressed in all black; his t-shirt read "Don't make me come down there -God." The other baptee was a very young man (20?) who seemed a little out of it and who I initially thought wasn't happy to be there. He was a skinny little hipster in saggy pants. I think he might've been a little touched, as they say.
Here's something I overheard today:
Pastor: Those who do not know Jesus are lost
Lauren: Amen
Me: holy shit (silently, trying so hard not to laugh I thought my head would explode)
I will end this post with the same observation I began it with: Pentecostals are awesome.
The first prayer was the hardest of the evening. The pastor's helper got up and said we're going to pray, and Lauren and I both put our heads down and suddenly everyone else has their hands up and they're saying, or yelling, or muttering "la la la HALLELUJAH! See la la ob la" and Lauren and I looked at each other and that was it for the next 30 seconds or so. I tried so damn hard not to laugh, but I guess the holy spirit was telling me to do it. So I laughed. Then we sang, loudly, along with a pianist, a drummer, and a woman with a great voice and a microphone. Lauren and I clapped, sang, yelled out hallelujah in between the songs ... They are really into repetition (the better to sing to) and I sang as loudly as I have ever sang without the aid of alcohol. It was wonderful, I felt good. I can still hear the songs in my head, over and over. The whole experience was holistic: the songs, the way people were so sincere, the smell of smoke lingering on some of the other participants.
Which brings me to other people in the church. They were diverse. Some looked like headbangers, and then there was the nice Christian family, with the girls in long skirts with long hair, and there were lovely old ladies who gave us hugs. Two people got baptized, one a young woman who would not have looked out of place at the Peacock, who said a prayer "for the father of my children, that he can find God" but she was with some other dude there, with long hair and dressed in all black; his t-shirt read "Don't make me come down there -God." The other baptee was a very young man (20?) who seemed a little out of it and who I initially thought wasn't happy to be there. He was a skinny little hipster in saggy pants. I think he might've been a little touched, as they say.
Here's something I overheard today:
Pastor: Those who do not know Jesus are lost
Lauren: Amen
Me: holy shit (silently, trying so hard not to laugh I thought my head would explode)
I will end this post with the same observation I began it with: Pentecostals are awesome.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)