Yesterday, after working and feeling pretty good about the whole undertaking, I walked Marvin over to JW's house, where JW and I chatted, then headed over to Goodwill. JW and I have this friendship that is very sisterly. We get asked, almost every time we're out, if we're sisters. We don't look particularly similar to each other, but apparently we have similar mannerisms. It's little things, maybe, like we both act like we're ladies when we go out. She's a lady, though, and I'm just acting like one.
So we go to Goodwill and begin our browsing. This involves us separating, looking at stuff, and then reuniting at different points to discuss what we have and me telling her "you have *got* to try that on! It would be fantastic on you" because she needs a little more courage to try on the (relatively modest) leather skirt. Certainly, one of our differences is that she dresses like a lady, and I dress like a cartoon character. Sometimes like a librarian, sometimes like a stewardess, sometimes like a square dancer. Always like a clashing, clanging noise of prints and colors.
We were looking through stuff, and I kept coming across this brand - you see, I have shopped at the goodwill so much that I can just scan sections and pick out things that I would like (old, bright, with union-made labels). And I kept coming across this brand, it sounded Scottish and it was very refined. A blazer here, a top there. And I said to JW "Some old lady must've just donated a whole bunch of this stuff, because it's all over, this brand right here!" And it was true. And that's scary, to realize that you can detect patterns in the donations at Goodwill.
I got a burgundy blazer, which I'm stoked about. We spent probably half an hour in the blazer section, and tried on about 10 blazers each. I also got a turquoise sweater vest, and my favorite: a pair of navy polyester slacks with a wicked pleat down the front, from Petite Sophisticates. I kept walking around, talking about my "Petite Sophisticate outfits" and, let me tell you, they are rad. I tried them on with this ridiculous frilly silky electric-blue top which fit funny (didn't get it) but when worn with the burgundy blazer, looked like I was somebody's crazy 80's aunt. New favorite off-brand? Petite Sophisticates.
Then we went to see An Education, which turned out to be awesome. Refined/creepy English people and growing up and adultery and beautiful old dresses. It was incredible. Then we walked around, got ice cream, and talked about the movie, and "mosquitoes," and life in general. Who we like, why we like them, who we don't like, why not.
My friend JW is a good friend. We know the faults of the other, if that makes sense. And yesterday was a practically perfect day.
Sunday, December 20, 2009
Tuesday, December 15, 2009
development as process
Grrup. Bup bup.
Sorry, just muttering to myself. Do you ever find yourself just walking down the street, totally talking to yourself? And maybe you're gesticulating a little, and even making faces to your imaginary talk-partner? No? Just me?
I have been talking in my head lately about climate change. Not because I'm a climate scientist. God no. But because I'm ambivalent, in the sense that I'm torn between two things, not in the sense that I don't care (misuse of the term, certainly). So I'm ambivalent - I am post-modern in my outlook, often. I doubt the scientific method because scientists tend to assume an ability to divorce politics and culture from research. It is not that Corporation A gives money to Dr. Scientist over here. But that Dr. Scientist, even if she weren't getting money from Corporation A, would be firmly enmeshed in the politics and culture even of her own discipline, scientific lineage, and so on.
On the other valence, I am more than irked by recent climate developments, and find myself (internally) defending scientific processes because, dammit, there's so much evidence for climate change and the role of mankind therein! The leaked East Anglia emails are only one source of my general irkedness; these emails do not, in any way, undermine evidence for the theory of anthropogenic climate change. They do, however, illustrate the very political, very culturally-enmeshed processes of science. I think there are really important lessons in these emails, which are being completely overlooked in the mad rush to interpret them as evidence for Mankind-Is-Doing-Fine-So-Carry-On (MIDFSCO) theorists, and their opponents, the Na-Na-We-Can't-Hear-You (NNWCHY) branch of the scientific community. Both are responsible for the characterization of these emails as either 1) completely undermining climate science, or 2) completely irrelevant to climate science. They are neither.
Climate science is political, and it is cultural. The sooner we (supporters of climate science, and by extension, the scientific process) acknowledge this, the sooner we can turn to the very political, very cultural implications of climate science. It is not enough to consistently assert that climate science is real; it is important to acknowledge that the very real evidence supporting climate change needs to be incorporated meaningfully in discussions about global business practices, inequity, and (good gods, save me) trade liberalization and its sister whores that birth bastards. We need to take a step back and look more seriously at the economic and cultural institutions that have created the problems we face, of which climate change is only a symptom, and find ways to overcome these problems. Sound cliche? It is. To the point of mundanity. And that's not even a word, says spell check.
On a side note, I was speaking with my friend M at lunch yesterday; she and her husband have been measuring carbon in mangrove stands around southern Asia. Her primary frustrations with this exercise involve the dumping of money by USAID into bottomless pits of corruption. My theory on global development aid is that it's window dressing. Since evidence points to global divergence (poor get poorer, rich get richer, increasing the gap) rather than the predicted convergence of post-WWII development schemes, the truth is that development is a failure. "Green" development, or giving money for carbon sequestration or other boondoggles, will not be any less a failure. How do we explain our failures? Why do we persist with these failures? On this point alone I am with the warming denialists: we are throwing money at problems, and this money will do nothing to stop warming. For one, we live in a post-colonial world that we completely fail to acknowledge. All those lines on the maps, the ones indicating that these people live over here, and those people live over there, those lines are all cultural artifacts, handed down and reified by generations. Now spell check says that "reified" isn't a word. FUCK YOU SPELL CHECK! At any rate, until we can acknowledge our past, and the ways that we have created the world around us, why would counting carbon in the jungle make any difference at all?
So how do we "develop" the developing world without ruining us all? I will work on this over lunch and get back to you (me).
Sorry, just muttering to myself. Do you ever find yourself just walking down the street, totally talking to yourself? And maybe you're gesticulating a little, and even making faces to your imaginary talk-partner? No? Just me?
I have been talking in my head lately about climate change. Not because I'm a climate scientist. God no. But because I'm ambivalent, in the sense that I'm torn between two things, not in the sense that I don't care (misuse of the term, certainly). So I'm ambivalent - I am post-modern in my outlook, often. I doubt the scientific method because scientists tend to assume an ability to divorce politics and culture from research. It is not that Corporation A gives money to Dr. Scientist over here. But that Dr. Scientist, even if she weren't getting money from Corporation A, would be firmly enmeshed in the politics and culture even of her own discipline, scientific lineage, and so on.
On the other valence, I am more than irked by recent climate developments, and find myself (internally) defending scientific processes because, dammit, there's so much evidence for climate change and the role of mankind therein! The leaked East Anglia emails are only one source of my general irkedness; these emails do not, in any way, undermine evidence for the theory of anthropogenic climate change. They do, however, illustrate the very political, very culturally-enmeshed processes of science. I think there are really important lessons in these emails, which are being completely overlooked in the mad rush to interpret them as evidence for Mankind-Is-Doing-Fine-So-Carry-On (MIDFSCO) theorists, and their opponents, the Na-Na-We-Can't-Hear-You (NNWCHY) branch of the scientific community. Both are responsible for the characterization of these emails as either 1) completely undermining climate science, or 2) completely irrelevant to climate science. They are neither.
Climate science is political, and it is cultural. The sooner we (supporters of climate science, and by extension, the scientific process) acknowledge this, the sooner we can turn to the very political, very cultural implications of climate science. It is not enough to consistently assert that climate science is real; it is important to acknowledge that the very real evidence supporting climate change needs to be incorporated meaningfully in discussions about global business practices, inequity, and (good gods, save me) trade liberalization and its sister whores that birth bastards. We need to take a step back and look more seriously at the economic and cultural institutions that have created the problems we face, of which climate change is only a symptom, and find ways to overcome these problems. Sound cliche? It is. To the point of mundanity. And that's not even a word, says spell check.
On a side note, I was speaking with my friend M at lunch yesterday; she and her husband have been measuring carbon in mangrove stands around southern Asia. Her primary frustrations with this exercise involve the dumping of money by USAID into bottomless pits of corruption. My theory on global development aid is that it's window dressing. Since evidence points to global divergence (poor get poorer, rich get richer, increasing the gap) rather than the predicted convergence of post-WWII development schemes, the truth is that development is a failure. "Green" development, or giving money for carbon sequestration or other boondoggles, will not be any less a failure. How do we explain our failures? Why do we persist with these failures? On this point alone I am with the warming denialists: we are throwing money at problems, and this money will do nothing to stop warming. For one, we live in a post-colonial world that we completely fail to acknowledge. All those lines on the maps, the ones indicating that these people live over here, and those people live over there, those lines are all cultural artifacts, handed down and reified by generations. Now spell check says that "reified" isn't a word. FUCK YOU SPELL CHECK! At any rate, until we can acknowledge our past, and the ways that we have created the world around us, why would counting carbon in the jungle make any difference at all?
So how do we "develop" the developing world without ruining us all? I will work on this over lunch and get back to you (me).
Sunday, November 29, 2009
viral meningitis
I believe I will write a blog post today, the day after a pretty wonderful thanksgiving break with my parents. I haven't felt like writing blog posts lately, but I have this great music playing in my head (via headphones; not crazy yet) and I'm feeling ... thankful.
I was sick about two months ago. I don't think I knew how sick, until recently. My parents talk about it like I was a ghost. One day, I think Sept. 21 or so, at this very computer, my head started to hurt. It got worse and worse, and I thought it was a migraine, something I hadn't had since high school. So I went home, got in bed, and just lay there for a while. For days. My friend J. and my roommate CS would bring me water and orange juice and I would periodically get up and vomit. Finally, my dad came to Corvallis and he put me in a car and I complained the whole way home. He'd bought about 15 different drinks because I was dehydrated; instead of getting anything normal, though, he'd bought Muscle Milk and similarly un-drinkable solutions. So I'd take a sip of a drink and tell him it was disgusting and then try another. By the end, he had nothing to drink and he said he'd have to burn the bottles because I had infected them all.
I couldn't eat or drink, because of vomiting, but mostly I had this headache, a constant, acute pain in the front of my head. My neck hurt and I couldn't bend my head forward, and I had to be in the dark, wrapped in a blanket, fetal position on the couch. I slept 16 hours a day, and when I didn't sleep, I sat in front of the fire or maybe, if I was feeling good, outside in the sun for a few minutes. I couldn't read, couldn't play boardgames, couldn't go for walks. The parents took me to a park one day because they thought I'd benefit from the sunshine and the walk, and I just shuffled behind them, saying I wanted to go home. They were dispirited, I'm sure, because usually I like to do things and I didn't want to do a damn thing.
Finally, they took me to a doctor who said she thought I had viral meningitis and my mom took me to the emergency room, where a doctor did a spinal tap (or "lumbar puncture") and a nurse gave me morphine. The morphine made me feel human, almost. The results came back at some point and the doctor said, yes, you have viral meningitis and you should stay in the hospital. I stayed there for four days, watching horrible TV and getting periodic morphine and hooked up to an IV. It was disgusting and dehumanizing. I was a parasite, completely helpless, without charm or grace. My smiles were fake, though I tried to smile because I was a complete dependent. The nurses were wonderful and they would come in and talk to my parents, who were often visiting, and they would talk to me and then, finally, they told me I could leave.
I went home, first to my parents', then to Corvallis, where I started to get a sense of myself back. My brain stopped hurting so much, though I continued to take naps for a few weeks and feel some of the same disorientation that had overwhelmed me during the illness. Physically, I started to get some strength back. I could play soccer, though I was much slower and felt almost wooden.
Now I look back on it and it's so unreal to me, that whole time. While I was sick, I kept just thinking, tomorrow I'll feel better and I'll get up and go for a run. Or I'll eat something, or I'll read a book. But then tomorrow came and my head was still just a bright sphere of pain on top of my body, and my back hurt and my neck couldn't move.
Thankfully, I didn't become addicted to painkillers (the pills make me puke), though I would happily take some more morphine. I didn't have any lasting brain damage, so far as I can tell. And life goes on. I would be such a helpless really-ill person.
I'm so thankful. Maybe my parents will see this post someday. We spent thanksgiving with my funny family and we ate a bunch and played foosball, then we watched some TV, cheering inexplicably for Texas A&M against Texas. Dad and I went running the next day, talking as we always do about 1) politics, 2) movies, 3) books. Mom and dad and my friend S. and I went wine-tasting, then we drank a lot of nice tequila and whiskey, then the next day mom and dad and I went cross-country skiing on Mt. Hood and laughed at Marvin, who was running so fast through the snow, just a black blur.
So I'm really thankful.
I was sick about two months ago. I don't think I knew how sick, until recently. My parents talk about it like I was a ghost. One day, I think Sept. 21 or so, at this very computer, my head started to hurt. It got worse and worse, and I thought it was a migraine, something I hadn't had since high school. So I went home, got in bed, and just lay there for a while. For days. My friend J. and my roommate CS would bring me water and orange juice and I would periodically get up and vomit. Finally, my dad came to Corvallis and he put me in a car and I complained the whole way home. He'd bought about 15 different drinks because I was dehydrated; instead of getting anything normal, though, he'd bought Muscle Milk and similarly un-drinkable solutions. So I'd take a sip of a drink and tell him it was disgusting and then try another. By the end, he had nothing to drink and he said he'd have to burn the bottles because I had infected them all.
I couldn't eat or drink, because of vomiting, but mostly I had this headache, a constant, acute pain in the front of my head. My neck hurt and I couldn't bend my head forward, and I had to be in the dark, wrapped in a blanket, fetal position on the couch. I slept 16 hours a day, and when I didn't sleep, I sat in front of the fire or maybe, if I was feeling good, outside in the sun for a few minutes. I couldn't read, couldn't play boardgames, couldn't go for walks. The parents took me to a park one day because they thought I'd benefit from the sunshine and the walk, and I just shuffled behind them, saying I wanted to go home. They were dispirited, I'm sure, because usually I like to do things and I didn't want to do a damn thing.
Finally, they took me to a doctor who said she thought I had viral meningitis and my mom took me to the emergency room, where a doctor did a spinal tap (or "lumbar puncture") and a nurse gave me morphine. The morphine made me feel human, almost. The results came back at some point and the doctor said, yes, you have viral meningitis and you should stay in the hospital. I stayed there for four days, watching horrible TV and getting periodic morphine and hooked up to an IV. It was disgusting and dehumanizing. I was a parasite, completely helpless, without charm or grace. My smiles were fake, though I tried to smile because I was a complete dependent. The nurses were wonderful and they would come in and talk to my parents, who were often visiting, and they would talk to me and then, finally, they told me I could leave.
I went home, first to my parents', then to Corvallis, where I started to get a sense of myself back. My brain stopped hurting so much, though I continued to take naps for a few weeks and feel some of the same disorientation that had overwhelmed me during the illness. Physically, I started to get some strength back. I could play soccer, though I was much slower and felt almost wooden.
Now I look back on it and it's so unreal to me, that whole time. While I was sick, I kept just thinking, tomorrow I'll feel better and I'll get up and go for a run. Or I'll eat something, or I'll read a book. But then tomorrow came and my head was still just a bright sphere of pain on top of my body, and my back hurt and my neck couldn't move.
Thankfully, I didn't become addicted to painkillers (the pills make me puke), though I would happily take some more morphine. I didn't have any lasting brain damage, so far as I can tell. And life goes on. I would be such a helpless really-ill person.
I'm so thankful. Maybe my parents will see this post someday. We spent thanksgiving with my funny family and we ate a bunch and played foosball, then we watched some TV, cheering inexplicably for Texas A&M against Texas. Dad and I went running the next day, talking as we always do about 1) politics, 2) movies, 3) books. Mom and dad and my friend S. and I went wine-tasting, then we drank a lot of nice tequila and whiskey, then the next day mom and dad and I went cross-country skiing on Mt. Hood and laughed at Marvin, who was running so fast through the snow, just a black blur.
So I'm really thankful.
Monday, July 6, 2009
For the love of the gods ...
So, I haven't posted in a long time. Neither has Mistress Redmore. Alas, we have found things to do other than go to church every weekend. Having exhausted the non-protestant possibilities in Corvallis, Mistress Redmore and myself are officially bored with it.
I have continued to meet periodically with my friendly Jehovah's Witness, A. We've had the talk, about how I'm not ever going to become a JW, and yet she still stops by now and then, leaving me nice post-it notes when I'm not there. My roommate CS has taken to leaving fake post-it notes, in the hopes that I'll mistake one for A's. CS is certainly a character. He makes good barbecue and enjoys drinking beer in the sun.
As for the title of this blog post, I went to Mt. Thielsen this weekend and came face-to-face with my fear of heights. It's good to stare down those fears now and then, lest they think they can get the best of you. I was climbing up, hand over hand, and thinking of the giant rock that was next to my house growing up. And wondering how in the hell I became so scared of heights, and when it happened. I don't know, but I feel the fear coming out through my chest when I'm up there.
As for the gods, I've taken to watching Battlestar Galactica. It's so good. It's interesting that the human characters are polytheists, while the machine characters are monotheists. I'm not sure what it means. Is polytheism more human? I'd like to think so. When I think of God, it's a guy in the sky, but in my most rational moments, I think that there must be a lot of gods. It only makes sense. Why would there be one? Aside from the holy three (Islam, Judaism, Christianity), doesn't everyone believe in multiple gods? Even Judaism (and its "jealous" god) and Christianity (and its trinity) are a tad confused about the whole "one god" thing.
For some reason, our culture has gotten into monotheism, and I don't like it.
So I'm going back to polytheism. I think it's a more natural way to look at the world. Everything around us is infused with the gods, and it's high time we started recognizing them. Like Mt. Thielsen - holy god of steep sides and hail in July. And hell, 4th of July itself, god of loud popping and bad suntan lines.
I have continued to meet periodically with my friendly Jehovah's Witness, A. We've had the talk, about how I'm not ever going to become a JW, and yet she still stops by now and then, leaving me nice post-it notes when I'm not there. My roommate CS has taken to leaving fake post-it notes, in the hopes that I'll mistake one for A's. CS is certainly a character. He makes good barbecue and enjoys drinking beer in the sun.
As for the title of this blog post, I went to Mt. Thielsen this weekend and came face-to-face with my fear of heights. It's good to stare down those fears now and then, lest they think they can get the best of you. I was climbing up, hand over hand, and thinking of the giant rock that was next to my house growing up. And wondering how in the hell I became so scared of heights, and when it happened. I don't know, but I feel the fear coming out through my chest when I'm up there.
As for the gods, I've taken to watching Battlestar Galactica. It's so good. It's interesting that the human characters are polytheists, while the machine characters are monotheists. I'm not sure what it means. Is polytheism more human? I'd like to think so. When I think of God, it's a guy in the sky, but in my most rational moments, I think that there must be a lot of gods. It only makes sense. Why would there be one? Aside from the holy three (Islam, Judaism, Christianity), doesn't everyone believe in multiple gods? Even Judaism (and its "jealous" god) and Christianity (and its trinity) are a tad confused about the whole "one god" thing.
For some reason, our culture has gotten into monotheism, and I don't like it.
So I'm going back to polytheism. I think it's a more natural way to look at the world. Everything around us is infused with the gods, and it's high time we started recognizing them. Like Mt. Thielsen - holy god of steep sides and hail in July. And hell, 4th of July itself, god of loud popping and bad suntan lines.
Wednesday, April 15, 2009
The Kat Lick Church, or: God is Society Writ Large
Um, I think I might have misspelled the title of this post. At any rate, I've been trying to write/dance my dissertation, and I'm starting to see double. So suck it.
Point is, Lauren and I ended our epic 40-day trials and tribulations (I gave up beer, Lauren gave up "tasty baked goods") and headed over to St. Mary's for some good, old-fashioned worshiping. When I say old-fashioned, I mean pre-dark ages. And when I say good, I mean that they're bringing back hot young priests! Praise Jesus.
So, the priest and his "sidekick" (technical term) were both Latin American, both attractive, and both about 30 years old. I don't mean to suggest anything untoward, but I think that you'd have to be an idiot not to think they're doing each other. If the Catholic Church hasn't furthered the cause of homosexual love, then I don't know who has.
The service: LOTS of people (over 200?), ethnically diverse for Corvallis, everyone well-dressed and on their best Easter behavior. There was a wonderful organist who was even better when he played piano. You could even say he got funky now and then. The singers had their moments of reaching-too-high, but were entertaining overall and added the magical-spiritual element to the whole service.
And now, to completely change the topic. I would like to share a jumbled and not well-organized stream of thought that's bouncing in my brain right now. I just read an article about the justification of indigenous displacement in North America, beginning with the Brits and following the progress of American interpretations through legal cases. American law, re. Native Americans, has boiled down to God's command to cultivate the earth (which the Indians, in our opinion, did not do) and to Lockean interpretations of private property. That is, property becomes yours through labor. But of course, property really becomes yours through legislative/governmental authority. I have a deed, therefore this is mine. And this deed, and our peculiar preoccupation with verifying and documenting everything and rationally arguing our case, has produced unanticipated consequences.
Hegel embraced contradiction. The French Revolution brought The Terror and mass executions. The Enlightenment brought dictatorship. And so Hegel said: there is a first moment, and it is the thesis. There is a second moment, and it is the negation, the antithesis. And there is the third moment, and it is the synthesis, and it reconciles the contradictions of the first two. And so history progresses, through contradiction. And the seeds of contradiction are seen in the first moment, in the very birth of whatever present conflict we deal with. Of course, Marx was a Hegelian. He saw the death of class society in capitalism.
And so, it appears that some Native Americans will regain control over their former lands through legal mechanisms. And displaced whites are claiming that they're being treated as "Indians," and are losing access to their lands, at least in very limited cases. And perhaps they're being displaced from at least some forms of access, and treated differently, maybe even unjustly, relative to Native Americans. And Native Americans are using the club of the conquerers to do it. They're using the club of legal displacement and inevitable (but regrettable) loss for current occupants.
And what will be the next third moment? How will the contradiction of American "self-sufficiency" and pride reconcile with our consumptivist society? Who will be our masters, and how will we die?
And the ultimate contradiction, for me. That I am a product of Euro-American Enlightenment thought, all scientific rationality and self-interest, and perhaps I am in as good a position as anyone to critique, at least for my own satisfaction, changes in my society that negate (or at least contradict) Enlightenment thought.
And the Catholic Church, the ultimate contradiction. In its bid to take over the world, it has transformed itself, absorbed local gods and goddesses, and taken on the role of multiple mystical systems of thought and worship and explanation, and so it has spread itself thin and perhaps, today, it is so thin that it is permeable. But other imperial excesses and mechanisms of cultural domination are at work. They are different. I think they involve neoliberal economic policy and instead of helping the Indian because he is childlike and needs God, they help him because he doesn't know about the market, for the love of Christ! Why don't we see what a little private property will do for him ... there, that's better. Look, his GDP is growing!
At the end of the day, I like what the Catholic Church has become. It has its faults, but it is dynamic. It is a product of the people, not of the pope. Damn him. Literally. He can go to hell, the one that the Florentines painted on their church domes, all agony and flames and demons eating people. But the Church itself, it is people. It is not structures, it is not dogma, and it is not Christ. It is people. So I'm a Catholic because I say I am, and because "God is Society Writ Large"(Durkheim).
Point is, Lauren and I ended our epic 40-day trials and tribulations (I gave up beer, Lauren gave up "tasty baked goods") and headed over to St. Mary's for some good, old-fashioned worshiping. When I say old-fashioned, I mean pre-dark ages. And when I say good, I mean that they're bringing back hot young priests! Praise Jesus.
So, the priest and his "sidekick" (technical term) were both Latin American, both attractive, and both about 30 years old. I don't mean to suggest anything untoward, but I think that you'd have to be an idiot not to think they're doing each other. If the Catholic Church hasn't furthered the cause of homosexual love, then I don't know who has.
The service: LOTS of people (over 200?), ethnically diverse for Corvallis, everyone well-dressed and on their best Easter behavior. There was a wonderful organist who was even better when he played piano. You could even say he got funky now and then. The singers had their moments of reaching-too-high, but were entertaining overall and added the magical-spiritual element to the whole service.
And now, to completely change the topic. I would like to share a jumbled and not well-organized stream of thought that's bouncing in my brain right now. I just read an article about the justification of indigenous displacement in North America, beginning with the Brits and following the progress of American interpretations through legal cases. American law, re. Native Americans, has boiled down to God's command to cultivate the earth (which the Indians, in our opinion, did not do) and to Lockean interpretations of private property. That is, property becomes yours through labor. But of course, property really becomes yours through legislative/governmental authority. I have a deed, therefore this is mine. And this deed, and our peculiar preoccupation with verifying and documenting everything and rationally arguing our case, has produced unanticipated consequences.
Hegel embraced contradiction. The French Revolution brought The Terror and mass executions. The Enlightenment brought dictatorship. And so Hegel said: there is a first moment, and it is the thesis. There is a second moment, and it is the negation, the antithesis. And there is the third moment, and it is the synthesis, and it reconciles the contradictions of the first two. And so history progresses, through contradiction. And the seeds of contradiction are seen in the first moment, in the very birth of whatever present conflict we deal with. Of course, Marx was a Hegelian. He saw the death of class society in capitalism.
And so, it appears that some Native Americans will regain control over their former lands through legal mechanisms. And displaced whites are claiming that they're being treated as "Indians," and are losing access to their lands, at least in very limited cases. And perhaps they're being displaced from at least some forms of access, and treated differently, maybe even unjustly, relative to Native Americans. And Native Americans are using the club of the conquerers to do it. They're using the club of legal displacement and inevitable (but regrettable) loss for current occupants.
And what will be the next third moment? How will the contradiction of American "self-sufficiency" and pride reconcile with our consumptivist society? Who will be our masters, and how will we die?
And the ultimate contradiction, for me. That I am a product of Euro-American Enlightenment thought, all scientific rationality and self-interest, and perhaps I am in as good a position as anyone to critique, at least for my own satisfaction, changes in my society that negate (or at least contradict) Enlightenment thought.
And the Catholic Church, the ultimate contradiction. In its bid to take over the world, it has transformed itself, absorbed local gods and goddesses, and taken on the role of multiple mystical systems of thought and worship and explanation, and so it has spread itself thin and perhaps, today, it is so thin that it is permeable. But other imperial excesses and mechanisms of cultural domination are at work. They are different. I think they involve neoliberal economic policy and instead of helping the Indian because he is childlike and needs God, they help him because he doesn't know about the market, for the love of Christ! Why don't we see what a little private property will do for him ... there, that's better. Look, his GDP is growing!
At the end of the day, I like what the Catholic Church has become. It has its faults, but it is dynamic. It is a product of the people, not of the pope. Damn him. Literally. He can go to hell, the one that the Florentines painted on their church domes, all agony and flames and demons eating people. But the Church itself, it is people. It is not structures, it is not dogma, and it is not Christ. It is people. So I'm a Catholic because I say I am, and because "God is Society Writ Large"(Durkheim).
Monday, March 30, 2009
Midget Ethiopian waiters!
This week we visited with the Pentecostals in Portland. And, in contrast to Corvallis life, we were 2 of 5 white people. This was a black church in the North part of Portland. So.... a recap-
Erin and I were very nervous at first. Mostly because even though we almost always are outsiders at the different churches we visit, it is never as conspicuous as when you're one of 4 white women in a large black church. All of my nervousness was in vain, though, when we were quickly greeted and welcomed to the church by almost everyone we saw. It was our obvious physical difference that made this welcome the greatest we have experienced at any service so far. Not only were we stopped by random women in the bathroom and hallways, but we received a special greeting during the service as first time visitors. It felt so warm.
One woman who greeted us before the service was a singer for the service and she said something that really struck me: "We all worship the same God." Erin told her that we were going around to different churches in Corvallis, but since we happened to be in Portland for the weekend, it was convenient to check out this church. So, we all worship the same God. It doesn't matter what denomination you are, because we're all going to heaven. Now, she probably wasn't referring to the fact that God and Jesus, to my people, are not synonymous, but I'd like to think that this was my warm welcome to an open church.
Some thoughts on the service
1) if you want good music that you can sing and dance to, go to a black church
2) if you want to wear your best outfit on Sunday, go to a black church
3) if you go to a black church on Sunday, make sure you eat a big breakfast to tie you over through the early hours of lunch
The sermon may have been the most directed sermon we have seen in a Christian service, as the preacher didn't ramble and actually made a point. They also had a pretty big baptism part of the service. They called people up who had just accepted God into their hearts and we watched as 4 people stepped up. The most touching part of this was when an ex-gang member was baptized and they led a large prayer for him.
We left after two and a half hours, hungry, and tired of watching people get baptized. I'm curious about how much longer the service went on for. I also have questions about what the difference between Pentecostals and Baptists are, as far as worship services, because this service was so different from the Pentecostal service here in Corvallis. Perhaps we will have to visit a black Baptist church to find out!
Erin and I were very nervous at first. Mostly because even though we almost always are outsiders at the different churches we visit, it is never as conspicuous as when you're one of 4 white women in a large black church. All of my nervousness was in vain, though, when we were quickly greeted and welcomed to the church by almost everyone we saw. It was our obvious physical difference that made this welcome the greatest we have experienced at any service so far. Not only were we stopped by random women in the bathroom and hallways, but we received a special greeting during the service as first time visitors. It felt so warm.
One woman who greeted us before the service was a singer for the service and she said something that really struck me: "We all worship the same God." Erin told her that we were going around to different churches in Corvallis, but since we happened to be in Portland for the weekend, it was convenient to check out this church. So, we all worship the same God. It doesn't matter what denomination you are, because we're all going to heaven. Now, she probably wasn't referring to the fact that God and Jesus, to my people, are not synonymous, but I'd like to think that this was my warm welcome to an open church.
Some thoughts on the service
1) if you want good music that you can sing and dance to, go to a black church
2) if you want to wear your best outfit on Sunday, go to a black church
3) if you go to a black church on Sunday, make sure you eat a big breakfast to tie you over through the early hours of lunch
The sermon may have been the most directed sermon we have seen in a Christian service, as the preacher didn't ramble and actually made a point. They also had a pretty big baptism part of the service. They called people up who had just accepted God into their hearts and we watched as 4 people stepped up. The most touching part of this was when an ex-gang member was baptized and they led a large prayer for him.
We left after two and a half hours, hungry, and tired of watching people get baptized. I'm curious about how much longer the service went on for. I also have questions about what the difference between Pentecostals and Baptists are, as far as worship services, because this service was so different from the Pentecostal service here in Corvallis. Perhaps we will have to visit a black Baptist church to find out!
That's some nice bling you've got there
After the successful completion of a half-marathon on Saturday near my hometown of Les Dalles, Lauren and I headed to Portland on Sunday for a day of soul searching. We went to the Emmanuel Temple church in North Portland, a black church. African-American church. Church of color. Actually, a church of beige, but with congregants of color. Of African origin. Long ago. Ahem.
As you can see, the very choice of a black church prompted soul searching: about the construction of race, whether we were more comfortable using the term "African American" or "black" (the latter for both of us), whether we would be welcome there ...
Turns out, we chose well. The Emmanuel Temple church seemed perfect because it's Pentecostal, a branch of God-worshipers that both of us really like. We approached the church along with some of the congregants, both of us a bit nervous. I could tell because we both mumbled and smiled a lot. As we walked around inside, I started to feel woefully underdressed. This feeling persisted throughout the service, as I admired the three-inch red nails of the woman next to me, the stilleto heels of the head usher, the purple zoot suit of a 60-year-old man. The service itself started with a lot of singing. There were three female singers, one male, two keyboardists, a drummer. And then the whole congregation, about 80 to 100 people, were singing along, sometimes clapping, hands often raised. The music was energetic and beautiful, and I felt comfortable singing, though I have to admit that the head usher had seated us very near the front and I felt a little conspicuous in all my whiteness. Mostly I was embarassed because I looked like a librarian, very plain and dowdy, compared to the jewel-toned jackets of the other women and the pin-striped suits of the men. At one point, newcomers were asked to stand, and Lauren and I stood and all these people came up to shake our hands and give us hugs. I was just giggling. It softens my cold cold heart to be surrounded by brightly-clad black people, by gum.
The sermon was delivered by a young-looking man who said he had a granddaughter (not so young, then), and as he began to speak, several people pulled out notebooks to take notes. I did not agree with everything he said; for one thing, he seemed to distinguish "culture" from "God," as though our God is not a product of our culture. This I reject. God may be real, but our interpretation of God cannot be divorced from culture. But he said some interesting things about culture, too: he used the metaphors of atmosphere and climate to describe culture. I like this use of culture, as something you take for granted. Like when people say that if fish were scientists, the last thing they'd discover is water.
The sermon-deliverer (is there a term for that guy, if he's not the pastor?) used biblical quotes well. They were flashed up on a giant screen behind him, and though the cynic in me noted a number of typos, I also noted that he had a remarkable way of using the Bible to substantiate what he was saying without falling into cliches. Also, he relied almost exclusively on New Testament exerpts, and he was entirely without condemnation. The sermon was about walking with God and Jesus, and making yourself better. It was inspirational, and toward the end his voice rose and fell dramatically, and he punctuated his statements with an AMEN!!! and an HALLELUJAH!!! and punched his fist into the air. The people around me yelled with him, sometimes clapping, though unlike the other pentecostals we'd visited, there was almost no speaking in tongues.
After the sermon, several people went up who had been recently saved. They were assigned praying partners and were all very emotional. I think one of the contrasts with other churches (especially cowboy church) was that there wasn't an expectation that everyone there was saved. Only that, if you were saved, you would need support and that support was available.
Something notable: the pastor and the man who gave the sermon were both comfortable talking about money. The pastor talked about those who haveth and giveth and all that, and how we should all tithe and give what we can, and how God lifts up your heart, your mind, your money. I was wondering if this was a cultural difference. Are white people so busy pretending not to care about money that they (we) resent being asked to give? Maybe. Or we're only comfortable being asked to give to NPR, in a jokey, ha-ha, aren't we all silly fashion? While at the black church, the pastor weaves together song and verse and requests for funds?
I liked the service, though we were there for over 2.5 hours, and I was starting to get hungry. Emotionally, I felt pulled in at times, though I also felt like an alien. I know this entry is disjointed, but I think I'm still processing the alien-ness of it all. It's weird to have so many expectations about a place and yet to be constantly surprised at having expectations met.
As for the title of this post, the pastor, in his oversized sapphire-blue suit, wore a giant gold watch. Several women wore ornate hats, including one covered in gold sequins. I went home and put on some makeup after the service, and I felt a whole lot prettier. Sometimes it takes getting a little out of your comfort zone to realize the value of something as superficial as a healthy coat of mascara.
As you can see, the very choice of a black church prompted soul searching: about the construction of race, whether we were more comfortable using the term "African American" or "black" (the latter for both of us), whether we would be welcome there ...
Turns out, we chose well. The Emmanuel Temple church seemed perfect because it's Pentecostal, a branch of God-worshipers that both of us really like. We approached the church along with some of the congregants, both of us a bit nervous. I could tell because we both mumbled and smiled a lot. As we walked around inside, I started to feel woefully underdressed. This feeling persisted throughout the service, as I admired the three-inch red nails of the woman next to me, the stilleto heels of the head usher, the purple zoot suit of a 60-year-old man. The service itself started with a lot of singing. There were three female singers, one male, two keyboardists, a drummer. And then the whole congregation, about 80 to 100 people, were singing along, sometimes clapping, hands often raised. The music was energetic and beautiful, and I felt comfortable singing, though I have to admit that the head usher had seated us very near the front and I felt a little conspicuous in all my whiteness. Mostly I was embarassed because I looked like a librarian, very plain and dowdy, compared to the jewel-toned jackets of the other women and the pin-striped suits of the men. At one point, newcomers were asked to stand, and Lauren and I stood and all these people came up to shake our hands and give us hugs. I was just giggling. It softens my cold cold heart to be surrounded by brightly-clad black people, by gum.
The sermon was delivered by a young-looking man who said he had a granddaughter (not so young, then), and as he began to speak, several people pulled out notebooks to take notes. I did not agree with everything he said; for one thing, he seemed to distinguish "culture" from "God," as though our God is not a product of our culture. This I reject. God may be real, but our interpretation of God cannot be divorced from culture. But he said some interesting things about culture, too: he used the metaphors of atmosphere and climate to describe culture. I like this use of culture, as something you take for granted. Like when people say that if fish were scientists, the last thing they'd discover is water.
The sermon-deliverer (is there a term for that guy, if he's not the pastor?) used biblical quotes well. They were flashed up on a giant screen behind him, and though the cynic in me noted a number of typos, I also noted that he had a remarkable way of using the Bible to substantiate what he was saying without falling into cliches. Also, he relied almost exclusively on New Testament exerpts, and he was entirely without condemnation. The sermon was about walking with God and Jesus, and making yourself better. It was inspirational, and toward the end his voice rose and fell dramatically, and he punctuated his statements with an AMEN!!! and an HALLELUJAH!!! and punched his fist into the air. The people around me yelled with him, sometimes clapping, though unlike the other pentecostals we'd visited, there was almost no speaking in tongues.
After the sermon, several people went up who had been recently saved. They were assigned praying partners and were all very emotional. I think one of the contrasts with other churches (especially cowboy church) was that there wasn't an expectation that everyone there was saved. Only that, if you were saved, you would need support and that support was available.
Something notable: the pastor and the man who gave the sermon were both comfortable talking about money. The pastor talked about those who haveth and giveth and all that, and how we should all tithe and give what we can, and how God lifts up your heart, your mind, your money. I was wondering if this was a cultural difference. Are white people so busy pretending not to care about money that they (we) resent being asked to give? Maybe. Or we're only comfortable being asked to give to NPR, in a jokey, ha-ha, aren't we all silly fashion? While at the black church, the pastor weaves together song and verse and requests for funds?
I liked the service, though we were there for over 2.5 hours, and I was starting to get hungry. Emotionally, I felt pulled in at times, though I also felt like an alien. I know this entry is disjointed, but I think I'm still processing the alien-ness of it all. It's weird to have so many expectations about a place and yet to be constantly surprised at having expectations met.
As for the title of this post, the pastor, in his oversized sapphire-blue suit, wore a giant gold watch. Several women wore ornate hats, including one covered in gold sequins. I went home and put on some makeup after the service, and I felt a whole lot prettier. Sometimes it takes getting a little out of your comfort zone to realize the value of something as superficial as a healthy coat of mascara.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)