Friday, January 2, 2009

I just love that God is so orderly

I went and met with the Mormons on Tuesday, and I've been meaning to blog about it since, but I was temporarily distracted by a ski trip on New Year's Eve. The skiing was fun, the fireworks and hanging out in the snow until 2 am were even more fun. But I digress.

I met with two of the sister missionaries at the LDS center right by campus: Sister B, whom I'd met before, and Sister H, who was new. Another girl (M) was also there. She was baptized only last spring, so I guess she's still kind of learning.

Sister B is very animated and likes to explain God through analogies of children and their parents. As in, "you know when your parents tell you to do something, but they give you a choice?" and she's always talking about God and you. I thought this might be an effective metaphorical tool, though I very much doubt that God is anything like a parent. Perhaps I view him more as a disinterested and ultimately unknowable entity. Very much in contrast with Mormon views; their teachings are all about being close to God, being "like" God (after the final judgement), and God's plan for us. It is a relationship that is personal. Hell, or the "outer darkness" is distance from God, the absence of God for eternity.

Sister H is very sincere and serious, and she is new to the missionary life. She looks quite austere and plain. She recently arrived in Corvallis, so I guess they have a kind of leapfrog system, where one sister replaces another and the remaining sister is there to mentor the new sister. I think it's a wonderful way to reinforce people's faith in the religion (probably the ultimate reward of the system, rather than gathering a lot of recruits).

We talked about the afterlife, mostly, and they read me some good quotes from the Book of Mormon. I once tried to read the Book of Mormon but I found it tedious; I had no frame of reference. It's much nicer when you're reading it aloud with some missionaries who can explain what they think is important. We talked abou the trinity, and they said that there isn't a trinity, but that God and Jesus are two separate physical beings. I do not understand how this can be interpreted as anything but polytheism.

The importance of the physical body cannot be underemphasized here. So much of what I've learned about their faith revolves around the actual, physical body (though God's is "perfected"). Here's what I think they believe (apologies for mistakes): before you're born, you're a spiritual entity, then you go through the "veil of forgetfulness" and you're born into the Earth planet and attached to a body. You're also attached to a family. When you die, you go to this planet (place) that is made up of spirits, where you can be in a relatively good place or a relatively bad place. Sister B explained it more as a state of mind - that we all go to the same place, but you can be there in a positive frame or a negative one. This is where God gives us a chance to accept "the Truth" and so spirits are going around, much like the helpful sister missionaries, teaching people about the Truth. Then there's judgement - sometime soon, I guess, since these are the "latter days" - and we'll all be placed in the hierarchy of planets (places) arranged for us: the celestial kingdom, the terrestrial kingdom, or the telestial kingdom (from best to worst, in that order). The absolute worst, though, is the outer darkness. After the final judgement, we are reunited with our bodies (though, I guess, they're "perfected" at this point, like God's). The celestial kingdom is where you want to go, and there you'll be with your family, and all your bazillion children, and God's there, playing pickup basketball or whatever he does in his free time. It sounds pretty airtight, huh? Around this time in our discussion, Sister B said "I just love that God is so orderly about everything" and I thought, this will never ever ever resonate with me. If there is one thing I believe about God, besides our inability to comprehend him, it is that he is not orderly. I mean, why did he feel the need to give us an appendix? That's not orderly. I think that the explanation of God's Plan is orderly, but I don't think that God is orderly.

Note about 19th century religions: for some reason, there are several common threads of thought that have been incorporated in many of these, including the importance of our physical bodies, rejection of the trinity, the revitalization of some truth that has been lost or obscured over time, and the return to a physical place (like Earth) after death. Mormons believe that they have the Truth, and that it will not be lost again, as it has been so many times. They also believe that God has many messages, or texts, but that the core of what we should believe is contained within the Bible and the Book of Mormon, plus a few assorted gems that I'd like to learn more about (Pearl of Great Price, Doctrines and Covenants). I didn't have time to ask what they thought of Gnostics or other heretics, but my interpretation of their beliefs is that Mormons are indeed "heretics" in the traditional sense of the word, which is why people like my grandmother don't like them. Me, I love heretics, but I digress.

My friend Amy was recently telling me about a couple of Mormons we know, and she said they were offended by the show "Big Love" because it portrays Mormons as polygamists. I think almost the opposite: the show really portrays the LDS church as the greatest opponent of polygamy, and the polygamists as more than fringe - they are shunned. Besides, I don't think that society's condemnation of polygamy is the church's greatest enemy any longer. I think that social liberalism and economic socialism are today's boogeymen for LDS. And liberals don't give a shit (usually) about polygamy. At least I don't. I associate the modern LDS church with heavy investment (literally and metaphorically) in material wealth and with an economically and socially conservative ideology. This is more problematic, in my view, than whether some guy wants a bunch of wives. Then again, I'm a raving lunatic. My point is, Amy was talking about these two Mormons, who are well-educated and (relatively) liberal and they had this gripe with a show that portrayed fringe Mormons ... and I think they're totally off base. I could be wrong, but I think that the major tests for the Mormon church will emerge as its adherents diversify and bring new thoughts into the fold. I can't wait for the first famous "feminist Mormon sociologist" and other radicals who will likely, someday, emerge from the bulk of teachings and seek to transform some part of them. And the resultant struggle, of course, as the Truth is tested, found wanting, and changed yet again.

Mormons like to use the word "agency" a lot. God gave us agency. Agency is the force of change in our human world. We'll see the Mormon church change, as it has already, as God gives people messages or as little girls look around and decide to incorporate Marxism into Mormonism ... it's not so unthinkable. And maybe God won't change, but as Durkheim said, "God is society, writ large." And so as society changes, so may God; it fits my thinking of God-the-unknowable quite well; we can infer all we want about God's intentions or plans, but in the end, he gave us a damn appendix and that is truly unknowable.

No comments: