Wednesday, April 15, 2009

The Kat Lick Church, or: God is Society Writ Large

Um, I think I might have misspelled the title of this post. At any rate, I've been trying to write/dance my dissertation, and I'm starting to see double. So suck it.

Point is, Lauren and I ended our epic 40-day trials and tribulations (I gave up beer, Lauren gave up "tasty baked goods") and headed over to St. Mary's for some good, old-fashioned worshiping. When I say old-fashioned, I mean pre-dark ages. And when I say good, I mean that they're bringing back hot young priests! Praise Jesus.

So, the priest and his "sidekick" (technical term) were both Latin American, both attractive, and both about 30 years old. I don't mean to suggest anything untoward, but I think that you'd have to be an idiot not to think they're doing each other. If the Catholic Church hasn't furthered the cause of homosexual love, then I don't know who has.

The service: LOTS of people (over 200?), ethnically diverse for Corvallis, everyone well-dressed and on their best Easter behavior. There was a wonderful organist who was even better when he played piano. You could even say he got funky now and then. The singers had their moments of reaching-too-high, but were entertaining overall and added the magical-spiritual element to the whole service.

And now, to completely change the topic. I would like to share a jumbled and not well-organized stream of thought that's bouncing in my brain right now. I just read an article about the justification of indigenous displacement in North America, beginning with the Brits and following the progress of American interpretations through legal cases. American law, re. Native Americans, has boiled down to God's command to cultivate the earth (which the Indians, in our opinion, did not do) and to Lockean interpretations of private property. That is, property becomes yours through labor. But of course, property really becomes yours through legislative/governmental authority. I have a deed, therefore this is mine. And this deed, and our peculiar preoccupation with verifying and documenting everything and rationally arguing our case, has produced unanticipated consequences.

Hegel embraced contradiction. The French Revolution brought The Terror and mass executions. The Enlightenment brought dictatorship. And so Hegel said: there is a first moment, and it is the thesis. There is a second moment, and it is the negation, the antithesis. And there is the third moment, and it is the synthesis, and it reconciles the contradictions of the first two. And so history progresses, through contradiction. And the seeds of contradiction are seen in the first moment, in the very birth of whatever present conflict we deal with. Of course, Marx was a Hegelian. He saw the death of class society in capitalism.

And so, it appears that some Native Americans will regain control over their former lands through legal mechanisms. And displaced whites are claiming that they're being treated as "Indians," and are losing access to their lands, at least in very limited cases. And perhaps they're being displaced from at least some forms of access, and treated differently, maybe even unjustly, relative to Native Americans. And Native Americans are using the club of the conquerers to do it. They're using the club of legal displacement and inevitable (but regrettable) loss for current occupants.

And what will be the next third moment? How will the contradiction of American "self-sufficiency" and pride reconcile with our consumptivist society? Who will be our masters, and how will we die?

And the ultimate contradiction, for me. That I am a product of Euro-American Enlightenment thought, all scientific rationality and self-interest, and perhaps I am in as good a position as anyone to critique, at least for my own satisfaction, changes in my society that negate (or at least contradict) Enlightenment thought.

And the Catholic Church, the ultimate contradiction. In its bid to take over the world, it has transformed itself, absorbed local gods and goddesses, and taken on the role of multiple mystical systems of thought and worship and explanation, and so it has spread itself thin and perhaps, today, it is so thin that it is permeable. But other imperial excesses and mechanisms of cultural domination are at work. They are different. I think they involve neoliberal economic policy and instead of helping the Indian because he is childlike and needs God, they help him because he doesn't know about the market, for the love of Christ! Why don't we see what a little private property will do for him ... there, that's better. Look, his GDP is growing!

At the end of the day, I like what the Catholic Church has become. It has its faults, but it is dynamic. It is a product of the people, not of the pope. Damn him. Literally. He can go to hell, the one that the Florentines painted on their church domes, all agony and flames and demons eating people. But the Church itself, it is people. It is not structures, it is not dogma, and it is not Christ. It is people. So I'm a Catholic because I say I am, and because "God is Society Writ Large"(Durkheim).

Monday, March 30, 2009

Midget Ethiopian waiters!

This week we visited with the Pentecostals in Portland. And, in contrast to Corvallis life, we were 2 of 5 white people. This was a black church in the North part of Portland. So.... a recap-

Erin and I were very nervous at first. Mostly because even though we almost always are outsiders at the different churches we visit, it is never as conspicuous as when you're one of 4 white women in a large black church. All of my nervousness was in vain, though, when we were quickly greeted and welcomed to the church by almost everyone we saw. It was our obvious physical difference that made this welcome the greatest we have experienced at any service so far. Not only were we stopped by random women in the bathroom and hallways, but we received a special greeting during the service as first time visitors. It felt so warm.

One woman who greeted us before the service was a singer for the service and she said something that really struck me: "We all worship the same God." Erin told her that we were going around to different churches in Corvallis, but since we happened to be in Portland for the weekend, it was convenient to check out this church. So, we all worship the same God. It doesn't matter what denomination you are, because we're all going to heaven. Now, she probably wasn't referring to the fact that God and Jesus, to my people, are not synonymous, but I'd like to think that this was my warm welcome to an open church.

Some thoughts on the service
1) if you want good music that you can sing and dance to, go to a black church
2) if you want to wear your best outfit on Sunday, go to a black church
3) if you go to a black church on Sunday, make sure you eat a big breakfast to tie you over through the early hours of lunch

The sermon may have been the most directed sermon we have seen in a Christian service, as the preacher didn't ramble and actually made a point. They also had a pretty big baptism part of the service. They called people up who had just accepted God into their hearts and we watched as 4 people stepped up. The most touching part of this was when an ex-gang member was baptized and they led a large prayer for him.

We left after two and a half hours, hungry, and tired of watching people get baptized. I'm curious about how much longer the service went on for. I also have questions about what the difference between Pentecostals and Baptists are, as far as worship services, because this service was so different from the Pentecostal service here in Corvallis. Perhaps we will have to visit a black Baptist church to find out!

That's some nice bling you've got there

After the successful completion of a half-marathon on Saturday near my hometown of Les Dalles, Lauren and I headed to Portland on Sunday for a day of soul searching. We went to the Emmanuel Temple church in North Portland, a black church. African-American church. Church of color. Actually, a church of beige, but with congregants of color. Of African origin. Long ago. Ahem.

As you can see, the very choice of a black church prompted soul searching: about the construction of race, whether we were more comfortable using the term "African American" or "black" (the latter for both of us), whether we would be welcome there ...

Turns out, we chose well. The Emmanuel Temple church seemed perfect because it's Pentecostal, a branch of God-worshipers that both of us really like. We approached the church along with some of the congregants, both of us a bit nervous. I could tell because we both mumbled and smiled a lot. As we walked around inside, I started to feel woefully underdressed. This feeling persisted throughout the service, as I admired the three-inch red nails of the woman next to me, the stilleto heels of the head usher, the purple zoot suit of a 60-year-old man. The service itself started with a lot of singing. There were three female singers, one male, two keyboardists, a drummer. And then the whole congregation, about 80 to 100 people, were singing along, sometimes clapping, hands often raised. The music was energetic and beautiful, and I felt comfortable singing, though I have to admit that the head usher had seated us very near the front and I felt a little conspicuous in all my whiteness. Mostly I was embarassed because I looked like a librarian, very plain and dowdy, compared to the jewel-toned jackets of the other women and the pin-striped suits of the men. At one point, newcomers were asked to stand, and Lauren and I stood and all these people came up to shake our hands and give us hugs. I was just giggling. It softens my cold cold heart to be surrounded by brightly-clad black people, by gum.

The sermon was delivered by a young-looking man who said he had a granddaughter (not so young, then), and as he began to speak, several people pulled out notebooks to take notes. I did not agree with everything he said; for one thing, he seemed to distinguish "culture" from "God," as though our God is not a product of our culture. This I reject. God may be real, but our interpretation of God cannot be divorced from culture. But he said some interesting things about culture, too: he used the metaphors of atmosphere and climate to describe culture. I like this use of culture, as something you take for granted. Like when people say that if fish were scientists, the last thing they'd discover is water.

The sermon-deliverer (is there a term for that guy, if he's not the pastor?) used biblical quotes well. They were flashed up on a giant screen behind him, and though the cynic in me noted a number of typos, I also noted that he had a remarkable way of using the Bible to substantiate what he was saying without falling into cliches. Also, he relied almost exclusively on New Testament exerpts, and he was entirely without condemnation. The sermon was about walking with God and Jesus, and making yourself better. It was inspirational, and toward the end his voice rose and fell dramatically, and he punctuated his statements with an AMEN!!! and an HALLELUJAH!!! and punched his fist into the air. The people around me yelled with him, sometimes clapping, though unlike the other pentecostals we'd visited, there was almost no speaking in tongues.

After the sermon, several people went up who had been recently saved. They were assigned praying partners and were all very emotional. I think one of the contrasts with other churches (especially cowboy church) was that there wasn't an expectation that everyone there was saved. Only that, if you were saved, you would need support and that support was available.

Something notable: the pastor and the man who gave the sermon were both comfortable talking about money. The pastor talked about those who haveth and giveth and all that, and how we should all tithe and give what we can, and how God lifts up your heart, your mind, your money. I was wondering if this was a cultural difference. Are white people so busy pretending not to care about money that they (we) resent being asked to give? Maybe. Or we're only comfortable being asked to give to NPR, in a jokey, ha-ha, aren't we all silly fashion? While at the black church, the pastor weaves together song and verse and requests for funds?

I liked the service, though we were there for over 2.5 hours, and I was starting to get hungry. Emotionally, I felt pulled in at times, though I also felt like an alien. I know this entry is disjointed, but I think I'm still processing the alien-ness of it all. It's weird to have so many expectations about a place and yet to be constantly surprised at having expectations met.

As for the title of this post, the pastor, in his oversized sapphire-blue suit, wore a giant gold watch. Several women wore ornate hats, including one covered in gold sequins. I went home and put on some makeup after the service, and I felt a whole lot prettier. Sometimes it takes getting a little out of your comfort zone to realize the value of something as superficial as a healthy coat of mascara.

Saturday, March 21, 2009

Cherry pickers

As my curiosity for new ageism peaks, mostly as a result of actually reading it, I believe that there is one thing I have learned: cherry picking is easy to do. In my readings from "Past Lives, Dreams, and Soul Travel," I find myself being extremely cynical about the Eckist use of the term/concept Karma. While they make it seem so easy- you're born, you either do good or bad, you die, and you're reincarnated with similar circumstances/souls- from my understanding of Eastern religions (specifically Hinduism), they are missing half of the picture. Whatever happened to Dharma? Now, I'm not talking about Dharma and Greg, the oh-so-whitty comedy from the 1990s. I am, however, talking about a life path, more or less predetermined by your status/the gods, that determines whether or not your putting in or taking out of the ol' Karma bank. Dharma and Karma go hand-in-hand. But these new age folk like the concept of doing good and paying it forward or doing wrong and being forced to re-live those circumstances in the next life (hopefully choosing to do right the next time around). They are completely ignoring the fact that Dharma has it all figured out already!

Furthermore... Yes! How miraculous that the great mahanta has come to speak to you in your dreams. Not only will he give you direction within your dreams, but he also speaks to other people in their dreams, according to your dreams. Isn't that amazing! Hello. Am I crazy to think that this is all happening in your dreams? Your enemies aren't going to have visions of the great mahanta in their sleep. They don't believe this-it's only you! If they forgive you in your dreams, it's not reality! They didn't actually forgive you.

One more rant (since I'm through reading the first 80 pages of the book and am therefore an expert). Do Eckists believe that the human population is stagnant? Maybe they've noticed that it fluctuates a little. How do they account for the fact that our earth is projected to reach 9 billionish (at a conservative estimate)? And when the ability for the earth to support human life suddenly drops and gazillions of people die, do they think that all of the souls that have been cycling through earth have suddenly been laid to rest forever? Maybe I need to go to the study group to get answers to these questions. Surely they have an answer for this. Or maybe I should sing a little hu song and the great mahanta will come to me in my meditation.

Sunday, March 15, 2009

Rambling cowboy talk, courtesy of Pierre Bourdieu

As I sit in the best coffee shop in Corvallis (the Interzone), eating my organic, vegetarian, yuppie-approved pesto omelette, I can safely reflect on the phenomenon mentioned by Lauren in her post: that of the strange convergence of cowboy and Walmart cultures, in evidence at this week's Cowboy Church. Whereas at the Unitarian Universalist church, reusable mugs are filled with shade-grown fair-trade coffee, the Cowboy Church, true to its nature, had styrofoam cups and (I assume) Folgers and little powdered cream packets. I didn't get close enough to confirm this, but I'm standing by my assumption. Why, you ask, does this matter? Well, it goes to the heart of Lauren's question. Taste is more than just what someone prefers; it reflects cultural capital, the set of tools that your parents give you. So while I seek out fancy coffee and ugly sweaters, others drink pop from a koozie and bring lawn chairs to church. It's more than preference, it's culture, and that culture has people who are "in" and people who are "out," secret rituals, shared belief systems, and so on. To the point, then: why the links between Walmart and cowboys?

Here's a theory: cowboys have happily stayed in 1950. Not all of them, but many of them, and their southern counterparts (rednecks), and especially that idiot pastor with the Texan accent at the cowboy church, like to think of themselves as "conservative" in the sense that the world is easily explained and morally unproblematic. Just remain stuck in an idealized circa-1950 Americana, and dismiss the overeducated organophiles as the ones who are out of touch. Why does it make sense, then, that they'd love Walmart? There was no Walmart in 1950, at least as far as I know. But 1950 was the pinnacle of belief in authority, technology, and progress. We were out of the war to end all wars, we'd defeated the greatest threat known to mankind (bad moustaches), and we were all set to mass-produce and optimize our way to a better humanity. The mythos surrounding this all was that we were building it ourselves, through some entrepreneurial spirit, or perhaps just pulling ourselves up by our bootstraps. Of course, the effort was fueled through massive subsidies, from the Federal Highway Act to crop entitlements. We performed perhaps the largest socialist experiment of all time, all in the name of suburbanization; in other words, comfort, predictability, and mall culture.

The material and social effects of this experiment have been numerous and dynamic. The 1960s and reaction against homogenization were one effect, and a line can be drawn directly from naked dancers at Woodstock to my happy eggs drenched in pesto. Another line can be drawn directly from the idea that government-subsidized vehicular development is somehow "all-American" and reflects a work ethic, and the cowboys with trucks displaying Calvins pissing on Ford (or Chevy!) logos. Those cowboys re-create the myth, they pass it to their children. They swim in the thought that 1950 was the penultimate expression of Americanism, not because of the fashion sense, which I might agree with, but because of the idea of self-development through progress.

One of the mechanisms of progress has been, ironically, to outsource production, fundamentally changing the economic and social structure of the U.S., but keeping in line with the underlying moral logic of 1950: the market determines what is good, externalities be damned. Walmart is a perfect expression of suburbanization and mass production, updated for the current day.

Cowboys and rednecks, of course, only represent one type of person who has maintained and perpetuated this mythos. The cowboy-rednecks identify with certain demographics (white, average or below-average education) more than livelihood; their cowboy hats signal membership in a club. Their rituals include listening to talk radio, shopping at Walmart, drinking beer from wide-mouth cans, and bitching about the government. Don't get me wrong - Walmart attracts all kinds of people. But as for why cowboys shop there, it makes sense. As for why I'm sitting here at Interzone, basing arguments on Bourdieu and debating whether to get a blackberry scone, that makes sense too. I'm a living, breathing stereotype.

Cowboy church? Like Lauren, I loved the music. It was wonderful. I could've gotten up and danced. But the Jesus talk was exclusive to the point of absurdity. At one point, after a little preaching, the pastor told us to close our eyes and raise our hands if we had "just been saved." Apparently, no one had been saved in the previous five minutes, so he said "well, I'll assume you were all already saved, then." As though he was so persuasive that if he hadn't just saved us, then we must already have been walking with the Lord. Of course, there's no room for those of us uninterested in his brand of salvation. Not in his church. I mentioned his Texan accent. Lauren thought that he might've been overdoing it for the sake of church. I agree. He was a fake-ass Texan cowboy, parading around and overenunciating every folksism. Jus' talkin a little truth, jus' lettin ya know what the LORD said and well, we jus' love gettin together and talkin about Jeyzus; can I get an AMEN?

I guess a question, then, is why I assume that he was fake and that the Unitarians are authentic. I think the answer is that I'm in the Unitarians' club, and so we've agreed to the truth of our message, we participate in the handshake, we sit in coffee shops, play board games, worry about the rain forest, and fall in love with ironic shoes (bless you, velcro).

Yippie-kai-yo-kai-yeh.


Erin and I finally visited the pseudo-impromptu cowboy church at the fairgrounds this Thursday. We were greeted by several large men in cowboy hats and cowboy boots and they promised us that we would really enjoy the service. We sat down behind a young man wearing a cowboy hat and and bright orange wranglers shirt with wranglers jeans. But that's not all... There was also a smattering of some Walmart culture, which may have been the most entertaining.

So they started off the service with a welcome to all the newbies. As soon as the rockin' band started playing church songs, a large man sitting near us opened a can of pop, which he had resting in a koozie. There were three large ladies who had brought their own lawn chairs because the hard plastic seats weren't lazy enough. I think Erin and I pointed out all of the visitors wearing velcro shoes- which she gazed at admiringly. Why is it that cowboy culture has somehow become connected with Walmart culture? Is it because they are major republican stongholds and maybe see themselves as underrepresented or underpriveleged? Maybe cowboy church is like a Nascar event where two cultures with a love for pop and sunburn find peace and happiness in the world?

Back to the service. What I expected to be hokey turned out to be the best church music thus far! There were 4 guitarists, a keyboardist, a bongo drum player and a drummer playing on an electronic drumset. One guitarist, whom Erin aptly nicknamed the Muppet lady due to her uncanny resemblence to a Muppet, sang some really beautiful songs, and this other guitarist was also a really good sliude guitar player. It was like a country rock'n'roll concert from the 50s. That was, by far, the best 30 minutes inside the oversized gymnasium.

And then the preaching started. And then I got nauseaus and thought I was going to pass out. Which was good because I had to get up and leave for a few minutes, which cut out some time from listening to the, thus far, most ignorant rant against non-Jesus lovers. The preacher deemed this "bible study," which I take a great deal of disagreement with because; a) I didn't have a bible, b) I'm not sure he actually even read a passage directly from the bible without distorting, I mean paraphrasing, it, and c) what were we even studying? I'm so confused.

The preacher basically spent an hour preaching about how only people who have accepted Jesus into their lives will be saved. He had us repeat an oath affirming the almighty presence and holiness of Jesus, which I didn't partake in, and when he asked us if anyone didn't believe the oath, I felt like standing up and shouting, "ME! I'm a Jew! Haha! I fooled you!" But I sat quietly in my chair just observing. The preacher would occasionally glance down at his watch, and I wasn't sure if he was buying time by spewing out words to fill the space or if he was genuinely concerned that we wouldn't get to hear all of the wonderful sermon he had in store for us. Either way, there's one word I would use to describe his sermon: logorrhea.

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

E-C-K

Those are my initials: E.C.K. And that is the "divine spirit" according to the ECKists, who praise the sound and the light of God. I wanted to drop this fact during our service, but I thought that it would be embarrassing for all of us if the six other adults (aside from Lauren and myself) plus 3 children got down on their knees right there and started worshiping me. So I kept it to myself. Waiting, waiting for my day when I shall reveal myself as ECK.

Lauren and I arrived at the little downtown building where the Starbucks and the Noah's Bagels reign, and proceeded to walk around in circles on the ground floor, then walk around in circles in the basement, searching for the elusive ECKists. Finally, after determining that the ECKists were upstairs, we searched for the stairs that went UP, finally giving in and asking the incredibly unhelpful young ladies at Noah's Bagels how to get upstairs, to which they replied, "there's an upstairs?" Turns out, for all the throngs who are trying to worship me, you have to go outside to find the stairs ... this is a temporary situation until they can find a cathedral large and spectacular enough to house my followers.

So it was a very small gathering, and pretty awkward. You see, this is a new age religion, and new agers don't like "structure" so much, and so we all sat around and listened to three people (all of whom professed some link to the counseling profession) tell us stories about "gifts." One of the women, a striking 40-something, started her story with: "I am clairvoyant" and I looked around, expecting smirks or laughter or something, but saw only nods. So I looked back at her, turned my face into a mask of seriousness, and nodded gravely. Ah yes, I thought, you're clairvoyant. And I am a vampire. But I said nothing. To my eternal credit and worshipfulness.

At any rate, I guess that the ECKists are into dream interpretation, which is cool. They're also into reincarnation. I was looking through one of their books, though, and there was a story about God telling a woman about her reincarnated cat, and how to recognize him in his new form. Um. Okay, followers: this is nonsense. I think that this is a fundamental problem with new age stuff: it kind of cheapens the whole belief system when things can be simplified and distilled down to this level of obviousness. Like when everyone says that their spirit animal is a wolf, or that they were Cleopatra in a past life. I mean, very few people say, "I was a cheap whore in Babylon in a past life!" Nope. Everyone was Cleopatra. And God gives a damn about your stupid cat.

That having been said, I could turn this criticism against myself, of course. I have only a simplified and distilled view of new age beliefs in general, and Eckankar in particular. I am sure that there is nuance in there. But in my role as amateur critic-of-everything, I have a hard time getting past the convenience of new age. I mean, take the nicest parts of Buddhism, give it a splash of Hinduism and a dash of mysticism and wrap it in some pagan niceties, and you've got a religion? Hmph.

Not my religion, by George. In my religion, all is mist and mystery, and you have to sacrifice virgins at the altar of ECK or your children will be eaten by ghost wolves.

In other news, I was visited on Saturday by my Jehovah's Witnesses, one of whom has now visited a few times (I'll call her "Ann"). Ann and I finished our discussion of suffering and Satan's rule over the world. See, there are 144,000 people who are going to go to heaven. The rest will return to Earth after God has reclaimed it. Satan was allowed to rule the world because mankind fell by eating something in the Garden of Eden. In my mind, it was a really good sandwich. Incredibly hard to resist. At any rate, after eating the sandwich, Adam and Eve were banished, along with all their progeny, from Eden, and destined to live short and brutish lives. Seems fair. Like I said, a delicious sandwich. But God (/Jesus) will return to restore God's rule over the Earth, put us all back together (even the dead ones) and restore peace and harmony to the world. It's all been an experiment! To show us that we need guidance, and that Satan provides the wrong guidance! The Holocaust! The million Holocausts that have occurred - just a big lesson for us! So I want to know: why do good people get the lessons again and again, and terrible people (here's looking at you, Dick) get to be Vice President and really rich? I guess that little girl running from Napalm in Vietnam was a really slow learner! Anyway, Ann is really nice and incredibly adept with her bible, and a lot of what she says makes sense. But overall, it makes about as much sense as reincarnating a cat.