Wow. This week, my mind is flooded with thoughts. I am going to start with a brief reflection on our blog. As you may or may not have noticed, our blog entries started as very jokey, I think. We filled them with as much sarcasm as possible, and perhaps even more than was necessary. And I think that this has changed over time. I can't speak for EK, but on a personal level, as we gained more experience in church and started to (at least mentally) create lists of pros and cons for different religions from our own worldview, I think we have started to see how religion can maybe work for people, what it fulfills in life, how we can benefit from it, and etc. And, especially for me, as I experienced religious ritual and grazed over religious basics, I have gone from not seriously thinking about them, to seriously thinking about them. And on that note, I have an annoucement to make: EK and I are going to join the UU church here.
Just a few thoughts on this: I never felt like I belonged to a religious community until I went to the UUs. Perhaps this is because it is non-creedal (or all-creedal as a friend pointed out after today's service). But this church is spiritual, the sermons are thought-provoking, the people are optimistic, hopeful, humanist, welcoming, and service-oriented, and there is an active community. I had a "conversation" with my mom today. She has yet to admit that she has successfully raised just one Jewish daughter-my sister. To me, it's not a question of Judaism versus ___(fill in religion here): it's a question of no religion versus ____(fill in religion here). Yesterday I found out that one of my friends in town (a very conservative Jew) was never able to come out to her Jewish community here in town. I find it upsetting to have to be untrue to who you are because of God or how God's words are interpreted. How can I belong to the Jewish community (or most other religious communities, for that matter) when they can't accept another human for who they are? I never felt such a love for a church and its community than I have for the UUs here in town, and I am actually excited to belong to a religious community for the first time in my life. It's oddly strange, though, that I started this journey thinking that I would gain a little more knowledge about religions, not actually finding home within one.
Now, getting back to our quest...
We went to the Church of Christ Science today. I am curious to learn more about Mary Eddy Baker. How did this religion, unlike most of the other more recent religions (see EK's latest Mormon entry) escape the whole body/mind connection? To Christian Scientists, it seems to all be a matter of mind over matter. God, combined with a right mind, can heal you. This blows my mind. I agree that there is something to health and healing in having a right attitude: Debbie Downer is always in the dumps. But it is scary to give up medicine of any kind! Do Christ Science members not believe in homeopathic remedies? Where does this all apply? Clearly I need to do more research on this. Perhaps this is to be saved for a visit to the reading room. Or a testimonial service.
The one thing that did strike me with this morning's service was how boring it was. Seriously, a monkey could lead the service. The woman and man who led the service literally followed a Christ Science-wide pre-fab service. This included nothing more than reading passages from the Bible and drawing connections to Mary Eddy Baker's work (which from what I perused was fascinating stuff). Basically, we were read to. The hymn's were pretty, but I almost fell asleep when we were listening to the service. I guess that is also a mind over matter issue, too... So, a lesson learned: you want songs, go to the Pentacostals, you want a good sermon, go to the Catholics. Whatever you do, do not attend a Christian Science church service.
Following this visit, we raced over to the UUs and made it just in time for their awesome guest minister speech. This minister spoke about spirituality, and gave 4 main ways to become more spiritual. EK took notes and I am sure she will post them on the blog. The sermon made me cry as I thought about what I could do to become more spiritual in my own life (note: that's a 100% tear-jerker rate for the UUs). Another thing that struck me about the service was the openness to creativity. This is especially in contrast to the Christ Science service, where even the church leaders had no room for creativity. This says a lot about how a religion views God... Is God flexible, unknowable, real, forgiving, kind? Or is God male, strict, linear/knowable (see EK's previous Mormon entry)?
All in all, interesting stuff from this week. I also read a book, The Reluctant Fundamentalist, which I will talk about when we visit with the Muslims.
Sunday, January 4, 2009
A Toofer Sunday
Today was a "Toofer," as they say on 30 Rock. Except, instead of getting the guy who both went to Harvard and is black, Lauren and I went to two church services. First up, The Church of Christ, Scientist.
This service was pretty sparse - I think around 25 people, including several single women. There were no single men. Lauren and I were greeted by a woman named Marcia, who gave us a pamphlet called the Christian Science Quarterly. This pamphlet guided us through the service, and when I say guided us, I mean that the pastors (one woman, one man) literally followed it word for word. First, there was a "scriptural selection" that was all about following authority, for authority is put in place by God. So, in rejecting authority, we reject God. The "responsive reading" was a collection of bible quotes followed by Science and Health quotes. They were tied together by theme, and this was fairly interesting, but the delivery of the message was as dry as could be. It was just word for word from the readings, with no interpretation, no joking, no creativity or application to what we find around us. As their Quarterly noted, "we shall now read Scriptural texts, and their correlative passages from our denominational textbook; these comprise our sermon. The canonical writings ... [apply] to all ages, past, present, and future, constitute a sermon undivorced from truth, uncontaminated and unfettered by human hypotheses" (Quarterly Explanatory Note). The notion of truth (or Truth or TRUTH or TRUTH) was extremely important to the Christian Scientists, and from what I could glean, this Truth is unimpeachable and good and, I suppose, does not need to be interpreted because it's laid out so clearly there in the Bible. All fine concepts, except you have to leave rationality at the door, for the truth of the Bible, in all its complexity and difficulty, cannot be reasoned through. It is told and absorbed, I think, and you just take it. As when the (female) pastor told us to accept authority; if the Bible is the ultimate authority, then there is no questioning the Bible. But if you (I) believe that the Bible is a human construction, then you (I) get a bit hung up on the removal of the human hand from biblical readings.
Now, I like a lot of things about Christian Scientists. I like the Christian Science Monitor, a great periodical. I like the emphasis on both the masculine and feminine attributes of God, and I like the rejection of the trinity. I read as much as possible from the literature they had available at the church - I like that they are believers in writing things down. Lots of magazines, books (by Mary Baker Eddy) and other information ... and they have Reading Rooms that are open to the public and that are quiet places to read! But I don't like that they are so devoted to dogma, and I don't like that they have co-opted the term "science." Science is a process, it is an outgrowth of our western philosophical traditions and the Enlightenment - in this sense, I am also dubious of some science, for it reflects our humanity and human perceptions and human priorities as much as it reflects some concrete Truth about the world. I skirt the post-modern at times. Anyone's use of the term "science" to describe a static Truth is a misrepresentation of science, in my opinion. I think that both scientists and very religious people can misrepresent science in this way; as a way to uncover something that is unchanging and real. I would label myself a constructivist in the sense that science (and religion) actually construct the world we find around us, rather than revealing it. But science requires evidence and reason, and so can change with new data; religion requires acceptance (faith) and so is unchanging. Problematic.
I'll try to describe a bit more of what I could understand about Christian Scientists: I think that most of what they believe comes down to the importance of the spirit, or the Mind, and the impermanence and even "error" of matter. I read a story in Science and Health about a little girl who injures her finger but then doesn't feel the pain and tells her mother that she is "all right." I think the little girl was supposed to represent purity or truth or something good, but I thought get the girl to a doctor. Sickness may be a mirage, but surely injury is not? Or am I wrong? But it gets to the point of what Christian Scientists seem to emphasize, captured in this quote:
There is no life, truth, intelligence, nor substance in matter. All is infinite Mind and its infinite manifestation, for God is All-in-all. Spirit is immortal Truth; matter is mortal error. Spirit is the real and eternal; matter is the unreal and temporal. Spirit is God, and man is His image and likeness. Therefore man is not material; he is spiritual.
-Mary Baker Eddy, from Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures (468)
After that rather dry and decidedly confusing service, Lauren and I biked over to the Unitarian Universalists, where over 100 people were gathered. There are two services every Sunday, an indication of how popular this church is in Corvallis. Perhaps because the church seems to fit Corvallis so well, it is a place of vibrancy and life and relevance. The sermon was beautiful and funny, delivered by a guest pastor. UU pastors are professional, something that is evident in the quality of their sermons, which pull quotes from a number of sources (including novelists, philosophers, scientists) and are delivered with humor and humanity. People laughed out loud, they clapped after a solo, they got up and shared their thoughts about the sermon. Every aspect of the church is meant to be inclusive; when the pastor told people to stand, he said "stand as you are able." The sermon itself was about how to be more "spiritual" - a term I kind of reflexively hate, but which was suitable for the sermon. So, according to this very nice (and we think Jewish) pastor, increasing spirituality may be done through asking yourself questions. 1) How can I be more compassionate, more kind; 2) What am I grateful for, how can I express thankfulness; 3) How can I be accepting and maintain integrity in the face of frustration, failure, and loss; and 4) What commitments and values do I want to be faithful to? These questions, provided without answers but with parameters and stories, were the core of his teaching. He did not say "FIRST, you must be compassionate." No, he started by saying that of all the religions of the world, compassion is what binds us. There are rules in Unitarian Universalism, or at least there are values, but UU spirituality does not require belief. It does not require that we kneel at a certain time or fast at a certain time. Again, I am speaking about UU in negative terms (what it does not mean) but I think it is more fascinating for what it does mean.
At any rate, Lauren and I have decided to join the Unitarian Universalist church. I'll call it a church, though I suppose that's not strictly true. It's a congregation or something. Whatever it is, I think that I'll join it and hopefully be part of it. I'll end this post with a passage from the Bible:
And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by men ... But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you.
-Matthew 6:5-6 (New International Version)
The UU pastor mentioned this in his sermon. What a powerful thing it is! That we should pray behind closed doors. That prayer is something we do "in secret." I have not seen a more powerful indictment of public prayer. Of course, elsewhere 1 Timothy 2:8, Paul says to "pray everywhere." To return to the Christian Scientists: which is it? Are we to pray alone? Are we to pray openly and "everywhere"? First Timothy is also the book that says women should be submissive; not just submissive, but they should not be teachers. They also shouldn't braid their hair or wear gold or pearls. I'm okay with not braiding my hair, but I refuse to give up the pearls.
Like I said, I'm joining the UUs. The literalists are not appealing to me.
This service was pretty sparse - I think around 25 people, including several single women. There were no single men. Lauren and I were greeted by a woman named Marcia, who gave us a pamphlet called the Christian Science Quarterly. This pamphlet guided us through the service, and when I say guided us, I mean that the pastors (one woman, one man) literally followed it word for word. First, there was a "scriptural selection" that was all about following authority, for authority is put in place by God. So, in rejecting authority, we reject God. The "responsive reading" was a collection of bible quotes followed by Science and Health quotes. They were tied together by theme, and this was fairly interesting, but the delivery of the message was as dry as could be. It was just word for word from the readings, with no interpretation, no joking, no creativity or application to what we find around us. As their Quarterly noted, "we shall now read Scriptural texts, and their correlative passages from our denominational textbook; these comprise our sermon. The canonical writings ... [apply] to all ages, past, present, and future, constitute a sermon undivorced from truth, uncontaminated and unfettered by human hypotheses" (Quarterly Explanatory Note). The notion of truth (or Truth or TRUTH or TRUTH) was extremely important to the Christian Scientists, and from what I could glean, this Truth is unimpeachable and good and, I suppose, does not need to be interpreted because it's laid out so clearly there in the Bible. All fine concepts, except you have to leave rationality at the door, for the truth of the Bible, in all its complexity and difficulty, cannot be reasoned through. It is told and absorbed, I think, and you just take it. As when the (female) pastor told us to accept authority; if the Bible is the ultimate authority, then there is no questioning the Bible. But if you (I) believe that the Bible is a human construction, then you (I) get a bit hung up on the removal of the human hand from biblical readings.
Now, I like a lot of things about Christian Scientists. I like the Christian Science Monitor, a great periodical. I like the emphasis on both the masculine and feminine attributes of God, and I like the rejection of the trinity. I read as much as possible from the literature they had available at the church - I like that they are believers in writing things down. Lots of magazines, books (by Mary Baker Eddy) and other information ... and they have Reading Rooms that are open to the public and that are quiet places to read! But I don't like that they are so devoted to dogma, and I don't like that they have co-opted the term "science." Science is a process, it is an outgrowth of our western philosophical traditions and the Enlightenment - in this sense, I am also dubious of some science, for it reflects our humanity and human perceptions and human priorities as much as it reflects some concrete Truth about the world. I skirt the post-modern at times. Anyone's use of the term "science" to describe a static Truth is a misrepresentation of science, in my opinion. I think that both scientists and very religious people can misrepresent science in this way; as a way to uncover something that is unchanging and real. I would label myself a constructivist in the sense that science (and religion) actually construct the world we find around us, rather than revealing it. But science requires evidence and reason, and so can change with new data; religion requires acceptance (faith) and so is unchanging. Problematic.
I'll try to describe a bit more of what I could understand about Christian Scientists: I think that most of what they believe comes down to the importance of the spirit, or the Mind, and the impermanence and even "error" of matter. I read a story in Science and Health about a little girl who injures her finger but then doesn't feel the pain and tells her mother that she is "all right." I think the little girl was supposed to represent purity or truth or something good, but I thought get the girl to a doctor. Sickness may be a mirage, but surely injury is not? Or am I wrong? But it gets to the point of what Christian Scientists seem to emphasize, captured in this quote:
There is no life, truth, intelligence, nor substance in matter. All is infinite Mind and its infinite manifestation, for God is All-in-all. Spirit is immortal Truth; matter is mortal error. Spirit is the real and eternal; matter is the unreal and temporal. Spirit is God, and man is His image and likeness. Therefore man is not material; he is spiritual.
-Mary Baker Eddy, from Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures (468)
After that rather dry and decidedly confusing service, Lauren and I biked over to the Unitarian Universalists, where over 100 people were gathered. There are two services every Sunday, an indication of how popular this church is in Corvallis. Perhaps because the church seems to fit Corvallis so well, it is a place of vibrancy and life and relevance. The sermon was beautiful and funny, delivered by a guest pastor. UU pastors are professional, something that is evident in the quality of their sermons, which pull quotes from a number of sources (including novelists, philosophers, scientists) and are delivered with humor and humanity. People laughed out loud, they clapped after a solo, they got up and shared their thoughts about the sermon. Every aspect of the church is meant to be inclusive; when the pastor told people to stand, he said "stand as you are able." The sermon itself was about how to be more "spiritual" - a term I kind of reflexively hate, but which was suitable for the sermon. So, according to this very nice (and we think Jewish) pastor, increasing spirituality may be done through asking yourself questions. 1) How can I be more compassionate, more kind; 2) What am I grateful for, how can I express thankfulness; 3) How can I be accepting and maintain integrity in the face of frustration, failure, and loss; and 4) What commitments and values do I want to be faithful to? These questions, provided without answers but with parameters and stories, were the core of his teaching. He did not say "FIRST, you must be compassionate." No, he started by saying that of all the religions of the world, compassion is what binds us. There are rules in Unitarian Universalism, or at least there are values, but UU spirituality does not require belief. It does not require that we kneel at a certain time or fast at a certain time. Again, I am speaking about UU in negative terms (what it does not mean) but I think it is more fascinating for what it does mean.
At any rate, Lauren and I have decided to join the Unitarian Universalist church. I'll call it a church, though I suppose that's not strictly true. It's a congregation or something. Whatever it is, I think that I'll join it and hopefully be part of it. I'll end this post with a passage from the Bible:
And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by men ... But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you.
-Matthew 6:5-6 (New International Version)
The UU pastor mentioned this in his sermon. What a powerful thing it is! That we should pray behind closed doors. That prayer is something we do "in secret." I have not seen a more powerful indictment of public prayer. Of course, elsewhere 1 Timothy 2:8, Paul says to "pray everywhere." To return to the Christian Scientists: which is it? Are we to pray alone? Are we to pray openly and "everywhere"? First Timothy is also the book that says women should be submissive; not just submissive, but they should not be teachers. They also shouldn't braid their hair or wear gold or pearls. I'm okay with not braiding my hair, but I refuse to give up the pearls.
Like I said, I'm joining the UUs. The literalists are not appealing to me.
Friday, January 2, 2009
I just love that God is so orderly
I went and met with the Mormons on Tuesday, and I've been meaning to blog about it since, but I was temporarily distracted by a ski trip on New Year's Eve. The skiing was fun, the fireworks and hanging out in the snow until 2 am were even more fun. But I digress.
I met with two of the sister missionaries at the LDS center right by campus: Sister B, whom I'd met before, and Sister H, who was new. Another girl (M) was also there. She was baptized only last spring, so I guess she's still kind of learning.
Sister B is very animated and likes to explain God through analogies of children and their parents. As in, "you know when your parents tell you to do something, but they give you a choice?" and she's always talking about God and you. I thought this might be an effective metaphorical tool, though I very much doubt that God is anything like a parent. Perhaps I view him more as a disinterested and ultimately unknowable entity. Very much in contrast with Mormon views; their teachings are all about being close to God, being "like" God (after the final judgement), and God's plan for us. It is a relationship that is personal. Hell, or the "outer darkness" is distance from God, the absence of God for eternity.
Sister H is very sincere and serious, and she is new to the missionary life. She looks quite austere and plain. She recently arrived in Corvallis, so I guess they have a kind of leapfrog system, where one sister replaces another and the remaining sister is there to mentor the new sister. I think it's a wonderful way to reinforce people's faith in the religion (probably the ultimate reward of the system, rather than gathering a lot of recruits).
We talked about the afterlife, mostly, and they read me some good quotes from the Book of Mormon. I once tried to read the Book of Mormon but I found it tedious; I had no frame of reference. It's much nicer when you're reading it aloud with some missionaries who can explain what they think is important. We talked abou the trinity, and they said that there isn't a trinity, but that God and Jesus are two separate physical beings. I do not understand how this can be interpreted as anything but polytheism.
The importance of the physical body cannot be underemphasized here. So much of what I've learned about their faith revolves around the actual, physical body (though God's is "perfected"). Here's what I think they believe (apologies for mistakes): before you're born, you're a spiritual entity, then you go through the "veil of forgetfulness" and you're born into the Earth planet and attached to a body. You're also attached to a family. When you die, you go to this planet (place) that is made up of spirits, where you can be in a relatively good place or a relatively bad place. Sister B explained it more as a state of mind - that we all go to the same place, but you can be there in a positive frame or a negative one. This is where God gives us a chance to accept "the Truth" and so spirits are going around, much like the helpful sister missionaries, teaching people about the Truth. Then there's judgement - sometime soon, I guess, since these are the "latter days" - and we'll all be placed in the hierarchy of planets (places) arranged for us: the celestial kingdom, the terrestrial kingdom, or the telestial kingdom (from best to worst, in that order). The absolute worst, though, is the outer darkness. After the final judgement, we are reunited with our bodies (though, I guess, they're "perfected" at this point, like God's). The celestial kingdom is where you want to go, and there you'll be with your family, and all your bazillion children, and God's there, playing pickup basketball or whatever he does in his free time. It sounds pretty airtight, huh? Around this time in our discussion, Sister B said "I just love that God is so orderly about everything" and I thought, this will never ever ever resonate with me. If there is one thing I believe about God, besides our inability to comprehend him, it is that he is not orderly. I mean, why did he feel the need to give us an appendix? That's not orderly. I think that the explanation of God's Plan is orderly, but I don't think that God is orderly.
Note about 19th century religions: for some reason, there are several common threads of thought that have been incorporated in many of these, including the importance of our physical bodies, rejection of the trinity, the revitalization of some truth that has been lost or obscured over time, and the return to a physical place (like Earth) after death. Mormons believe that they have the Truth, and that it will not be lost again, as it has been so many times. They also believe that God has many messages, or texts, but that the core of what we should believe is contained within the Bible and the Book of Mormon, plus a few assorted gems that I'd like to learn more about (Pearl of Great Price, Doctrines and Covenants). I didn't have time to ask what they thought of Gnostics or other heretics, but my interpretation of their beliefs is that Mormons are indeed "heretics" in the traditional sense of the word, which is why people like my grandmother don't like them. Me, I love heretics, but I digress.
My friend Amy was recently telling me about a couple of Mormons we know, and she said they were offended by the show "Big Love" because it portrays Mormons as polygamists. I think almost the opposite: the show really portrays the LDS church as the greatest opponent of polygamy, and the polygamists as more than fringe - they are shunned. Besides, I don't think that society's condemnation of polygamy is the church's greatest enemy any longer. I think that social liberalism and economic socialism are today's boogeymen for LDS. And liberals don't give a shit (usually) about polygamy. At least I don't. I associate the modern LDS church with heavy investment (literally and metaphorically) in material wealth and with an economically and socially conservative ideology. This is more problematic, in my view, than whether some guy wants a bunch of wives. Then again, I'm a raving lunatic. My point is, Amy was talking about these two Mormons, who are well-educated and (relatively) liberal and they had this gripe with a show that portrayed fringe Mormons ... and I think they're totally off base. I could be wrong, but I think that the major tests for the Mormon church will emerge as its adherents diversify and bring new thoughts into the fold. I can't wait for the first famous "feminist Mormon sociologist" and other radicals who will likely, someday, emerge from the bulk of teachings and seek to transform some part of them. And the resultant struggle, of course, as the Truth is tested, found wanting, and changed yet again.
Mormons like to use the word "agency" a lot. God gave us agency. Agency is the force of change in our human world. We'll see the Mormon church change, as it has already, as God gives people messages or as little girls look around and decide to incorporate Marxism into Mormonism ... it's not so unthinkable. And maybe God won't change, but as Durkheim said, "God is society, writ large." And so as society changes, so may God; it fits my thinking of God-the-unknowable quite well; we can infer all we want about God's intentions or plans, but in the end, he gave us a damn appendix and that is truly unknowable.
I met with two of the sister missionaries at the LDS center right by campus: Sister B, whom I'd met before, and Sister H, who was new. Another girl (M) was also there. She was baptized only last spring, so I guess she's still kind of learning.
Sister B is very animated and likes to explain God through analogies of children and their parents. As in, "you know when your parents tell you to do something, but they give you a choice?" and she's always talking about God and you. I thought this might be an effective metaphorical tool, though I very much doubt that God is anything like a parent. Perhaps I view him more as a disinterested and ultimately unknowable entity. Very much in contrast with Mormon views; their teachings are all about being close to God, being "like" God (after the final judgement), and God's plan for us. It is a relationship that is personal. Hell, or the "outer darkness" is distance from God, the absence of God for eternity.
Sister H is very sincere and serious, and she is new to the missionary life. She looks quite austere and plain. She recently arrived in Corvallis, so I guess they have a kind of leapfrog system, where one sister replaces another and the remaining sister is there to mentor the new sister. I think it's a wonderful way to reinforce people's faith in the religion (probably the ultimate reward of the system, rather than gathering a lot of recruits).
We talked about the afterlife, mostly, and they read me some good quotes from the Book of Mormon. I once tried to read the Book of Mormon but I found it tedious; I had no frame of reference. It's much nicer when you're reading it aloud with some missionaries who can explain what they think is important. We talked abou the trinity, and they said that there isn't a trinity, but that God and Jesus are two separate physical beings. I do not understand how this can be interpreted as anything but polytheism.
The importance of the physical body cannot be underemphasized here. So much of what I've learned about their faith revolves around the actual, physical body (though God's is "perfected"). Here's what I think they believe (apologies for mistakes): before you're born, you're a spiritual entity, then you go through the "veil of forgetfulness" and you're born into the Earth planet and attached to a body. You're also attached to a family. When you die, you go to this planet (place) that is made up of spirits, where you can be in a relatively good place or a relatively bad place. Sister B explained it more as a state of mind - that we all go to the same place, but you can be there in a positive frame or a negative one. This is where God gives us a chance to accept "the Truth" and so spirits are going around, much like the helpful sister missionaries, teaching people about the Truth. Then there's judgement - sometime soon, I guess, since these are the "latter days" - and we'll all be placed in the hierarchy of planets (places) arranged for us: the celestial kingdom, the terrestrial kingdom, or the telestial kingdom (from best to worst, in that order). The absolute worst, though, is the outer darkness. After the final judgement, we are reunited with our bodies (though, I guess, they're "perfected" at this point, like God's). The celestial kingdom is where you want to go, and there you'll be with your family, and all your bazillion children, and God's there, playing pickup basketball or whatever he does in his free time. It sounds pretty airtight, huh? Around this time in our discussion, Sister B said "I just love that God is so orderly about everything" and I thought, this will never ever ever resonate with me. If there is one thing I believe about God, besides our inability to comprehend him, it is that he is not orderly. I mean, why did he feel the need to give us an appendix? That's not orderly. I think that the explanation of God's Plan is orderly, but I don't think that God is orderly.
Note about 19th century religions: for some reason, there are several common threads of thought that have been incorporated in many of these, including the importance of our physical bodies, rejection of the trinity, the revitalization of some truth that has been lost or obscured over time, and the return to a physical place (like Earth) after death. Mormons believe that they have the Truth, and that it will not be lost again, as it has been so many times. They also believe that God has many messages, or texts, but that the core of what we should believe is contained within the Bible and the Book of Mormon, plus a few assorted gems that I'd like to learn more about (Pearl of Great Price, Doctrines and Covenants). I didn't have time to ask what they thought of Gnostics or other heretics, but my interpretation of their beliefs is that Mormons are indeed "heretics" in the traditional sense of the word, which is why people like my grandmother don't like them. Me, I love heretics, but I digress.
My friend Amy was recently telling me about a couple of Mormons we know, and she said they were offended by the show "Big Love" because it portrays Mormons as polygamists. I think almost the opposite: the show really portrays the LDS church as the greatest opponent of polygamy, and the polygamists as more than fringe - they are shunned. Besides, I don't think that society's condemnation of polygamy is the church's greatest enemy any longer. I think that social liberalism and economic socialism are today's boogeymen for LDS. And liberals don't give a shit (usually) about polygamy. At least I don't. I associate the modern LDS church with heavy investment (literally and metaphorically) in material wealth and with an economically and socially conservative ideology. This is more problematic, in my view, than whether some guy wants a bunch of wives. Then again, I'm a raving lunatic. My point is, Amy was talking about these two Mormons, who are well-educated and (relatively) liberal and they had this gripe with a show that portrayed fringe Mormons ... and I think they're totally off base. I could be wrong, but I think that the major tests for the Mormon church will emerge as its adherents diversify and bring new thoughts into the fold. I can't wait for the first famous "feminist Mormon sociologist" and other radicals who will likely, someday, emerge from the bulk of teachings and seek to transform some part of them. And the resultant struggle, of course, as the Truth is tested, found wanting, and changed yet again.
Mormons like to use the word "agency" a lot. God gave us agency. Agency is the force of change in our human world. We'll see the Mormon church change, as it has already, as God gives people messages or as little girls look around and decide to incorporate Marxism into Mormonism ... it's not so unthinkable. And maybe God won't change, but as Durkheim said, "God is society, writ large." And so as society changes, so may God; it fits my thinking of God-the-unknowable quite well; we can infer all we want about God's intentions or plans, but in the end, he gave us a damn appendix and that is truly unknowable.
Sunday, December 28, 2008
You had me at "Hello"...
Well, actually you had me at "We're more pagan and humanists than anything else."
This week we ventured into the Unitarian Universalist congregation and I fell in love. We met some of the lay ministers when we first arrived and I believe that there was the assumption that EK and I were partners (in the physical and spiritual sense). Generally wherever she and I go, people might think that we are lesbians, but this is the first time anyone asked us outright. And the wonderful part of it all is that there was NO judgement made towards us either way. In fact, we would have been one of many lesbian couples at the service (including the minister herself).
The greatest thing about the UU church, in my humble opinion, is that they have succeeded in doing what I dislike about most religions-they took the "God" out of the church. This, to me, is like the ultimate Baha'i: we can be humanists, we can believe in freedom for all, yet we can talk about politics and liberalism and peace on earth and we don't have to make God part of the conversation within the congregation. Let's keep God to ourselves, meditate upon what it means to have a belief or not have a belief, and let's be a community of hope. Radical. I might be sold!
I was struck by the community themselves. There were a lot of older people, or "gray heads" as I like to call them, and definitely a feminist slant. There were probably 75% women, many of whom were there with their partners, with short hair styles (as EK and I just discussed), and without bras. I have hear about the large hippie community in our town, and I think I found where most of them go to church.
The service was very emotional for me. The moment for sharing thoughts was followed by a lighting of candles/sharing of "joys and sorrows" when we heard stories of death, pregnancies, and etc. I was moved to tears several times. This was followed by a moment of meditation, which was really the best part of my day (other than the coffee and cookies social hour post-service). We also sang some songs (not as fun as the Pentacostals) and we ended service with meeting our neighbors.
I'm going to read more about the UU's, and I may or may not have found a community with which I can actually belong.
Now, a brief thought on EK's previous entry:
Another time, he was marching through the ice when he had this thought: "Then I grasped the meaning of the greatest secret that human poetry and human thought and belief have to impart: The salvation of man is through love and in love." How did he not want those Nazis to suffer as he had?
This idea of unconditional love: can it ever truly exist? I think of our housemate whose friend, despite (or because of) a broken relationship with his father, saw his father through his dying days. This is truly heaven to me. The ability to love is an incredible gift. Without it we are lost and unhappy. Perhaps the UU's can provide the community support that might somehow help me to get closer to unconditional love. Sigh.
This week we ventured into the Unitarian Universalist congregation and I fell in love. We met some of the lay ministers when we first arrived and I believe that there was the assumption that EK and I were partners (in the physical and spiritual sense). Generally wherever she and I go, people might think that we are lesbians, but this is the first time anyone asked us outright. And the wonderful part of it all is that there was NO judgement made towards us either way. In fact, we would have been one of many lesbian couples at the service (including the minister herself).
The greatest thing about the UU church, in my humble opinion, is that they have succeeded in doing what I dislike about most religions-they took the "God" out of the church. This, to me, is like the ultimate Baha'i: we can be humanists, we can believe in freedom for all, yet we can talk about politics and liberalism and peace on earth and we don't have to make God part of the conversation within the congregation. Let's keep God to ourselves, meditate upon what it means to have a belief or not have a belief, and let's be a community of hope. Radical. I might be sold!
I was struck by the community themselves. There were a lot of older people, or "gray heads" as I like to call them, and definitely a feminist slant. There were probably 75% women, many of whom were there with their partners, with short hair styles (as EK and I just discussed), and without bras. I have hear about the large hippie community in our town, and I think I found where most of them go to church.
The service was very emotional for me. The moment for sharing thoughts was followed by a lighting of candles/sharing of "joys and sorrows" when we heard stories of death, pregnancies, and etc. I was moved to tears several times. This was followed by a moment of meditation, which was really the best part of my day (other than the coffee and cookies social hour post-service). We also sang some songs (not as fun as the Pentacostals) and we ended service with meeting our neighbors.
I'm going to read more about the UU's, and I may or may not have found a community with which I can actually belong.
Now, a brief thought on EK's previous entry:
Another time, he was marching through the ice when he had this thought: "Then I grasped the meaning of the greatest secret that human poetry and human thought and belief have to impart: The salvation of man is through love and in love." How did he not want those Nazis to suffer as he had?
This idea of unconditional love: can it ever truly exist? I think of our housemate whose friend, despite (or because of) a broken relationship with his father, saw his father through his dying days. This is truly heaven to me. The ability to love is an incredible gift. Without it we are lost and unhappy. Perhaps the UU's can provide the community support that might somehow help me to get closer to unconditional love. Sigh.
Are you partners? And other greetings at the Unitarian Universalist Fellowship of Corvallis
Lauren and I decided to go to the Unitarian Universalists today. We rode our bikes there and were early, so we helped some peeps there set up. I helped by breaking the leg off a sign. Oh well. The friendly people (mostly old, gotta admit) shuffled around, putting things in order and trying to make us feel comfortable.
The service itself was wonderful. Singing, a little meditating, some heartfelt wishes, the goodbyes to their pastor who is going on sabbatical. There were over 100 people there and they were a diverse group, though heavily trended toward: 1) older, 2) liberal (!), and 3) white (it is Corvallis). I teared up a few times during the service and I felt like it was the best service I've been to. Maybe the Pentecostals are close, but this was a community of people that I was comfortable with on many levels. They are non-dogmatic but committed to particular values, primarily social justice. And one of the women we spoke to assumed we were a couple but broached the topic in such a nice, unassuming way (hence the title of this post).
In terms of the history of the whole thing:
Unitarians - they do not believe that Jesus was divine (rejection of the trinity)
Universalists - they do not believe that people are going to hell
The two groups collided to bring you friendly people who like to drink coffee, eat cookies, and wear rainbow scarves. Their website also proudly states that they have "always been heretics." And though I phrased their beliefs in terms of what they do not believe in, I think that what they do believe in is just as interesting (plagiarized and paraphrased from a little booklet we received):
"1) The inherent worth and dignity of every person
2) Justice, equity and compassion in human relations
3) Acceptance of one another and encouragement to spiritual growth
4) A free and responsible search for truth and meaning
5) The right of conscience and the use of the democratic process
6) The goal of world community with peace, liberty, and justice for all
7) Respect for the interdependent web of all existence"
These values are my values: what they say and what they do not say. I especially like that they included #5, the right of conscience and the use of the democratic process. As one woman said to me: "Deeds, not creeds." Exactamundo. The assumption that we are united by sin and defect is replaced with the assumption that we are united through love and possibility. And the rejection of the trinity is important to me on a weird level. I can't explain it, but I don't like the trinity. To me, it's a three-headed monster of history. It represents the oppression and hypocrisy of the church as it became a political beast under Constantine. It is a symbol of the dominance and hierarchy of modern Christian churches, particularly Catholicism.
The Unitarian Universalists may be the church that I go to. At least for now, I feel that I embrace their values and yet I do not have to suspend my disbelief. I just fit there.
But certainly, I will continue to go to other churches. I have thought about why we are actually doing this, and I have a few reasons. One: I am interested in Corvallis and the communities of people who exist here, side by side, but who can see the world so differently. Two: I like religions, in particular religious history, and I think that even a superficial knowledge of what people believe is good for my brain. Three: I think that maybe, somehow, I'll find a religion that I can believe in.
The service itself was wonderful. Singing, a little meditating, some heartfelt wishes, the goodbyes to their pastor who is going on sabbatical. There were over 100 people there and they were a diverse group, though heavily trended toward: 1) older, 2) liberal (!), and 3) white (it is Corvallis). I teared up a few times during the service and I felt like it was the best service I've been to. Maybe the Pentecostals are close, but this was a community of people that I was comfortable with on many levels. They are non-dogmatic but committed to particular values, primarily social justice. And one of the women we spoke to assumed we were a couple but broached the topic in such a nice, unassuming way (hence the title of this post).
In terms of the history of the whole thing:
Unitarians - they do not believe that Jesus was divine (rejection of the trinity)
Universalists - they do not believe that people are going to hell
The two groups collided to bring you friendly people who like to drink coffee, eat cookies, and wear rainbow scarves. Their website also proudly states that they have "always been heretics." And though I phrased their beliefs in terms of what they do not believe in, I think that what they do believe in is just as interesting (plagiarized and paraphrased from a little booklet we received):
"1) The inherent worth and dignity of every person
2) Justice, equity and compassion in human relations
3) Acceptance of one another and encouragement to spiritual growth
4) A free and responsible search for truth and meaning
5) The right of conscience and the use of the democratic process
6) The goal of world community with peace, liberty, and justice for all
7) Respect for the interdependent web of all existence"
These values are my values: what they say and what they do not say. I especially like that they included #5, the right of conscience and the use of the democratic process. As one woman said to me: "Deeds, not creeds." Exactamundo. The assumption that we are united by sin and defect is replaced with the assumption that we are united through love and possibility. And the rejection of the trinity is important to me on a weird level. I can't explain it, but I don't like the trinity. To me, it's a three-headed monster of history. It represents the oppression and hypocrisy of the church as it became a political beast under Constantine. It is a symbol of the dominance and hierarchy of modern Christian churches, particularly Catholicism.
The Unitarian Universalists may be the church that I go to. At least for now, I feel that I embrace their values and yet I do not have to suspend my disbelief. I just fit there.
But certainly, I will continue to go to other churches. I have thought about why we are actually doing this, and I have a few reasons. One: I am interested in Corvallis and the communities of people who exist here, side by side, but who can see the world so differently. Two: I like religions, in particular religious history, and I think that even a superficial knowledge of what people believe is good for my brain. Three: I think that maybe, somehow, I'll find a religion that I can believe in.
Thursday, December 25, 2008
Do you have something else to wear? And other Christmas greetings.
I thought I'd throw out a quick blog for Christmas. Merry Christmas! And I thought I'd respond to one of your comments, Lauren, about Jews. That is, you mentioned that
Liberal Jews (probably excluding Israelis) acknowledge that the conquest of Israel/Palestine is an expression of symbolic capital: Jews are expressing their strength, mainly in military and wealth.
Interesting thought. I would think there are a number of Israelis who are liberal, and so probably recognize that 1) Israel/Palestine has been "conquered" and that 2) this is a show of strength. But it's an odd bind, isn't it, to be both socially liberal and to be supportive of a militant government? I guess that "socially-conscious" doesn't necessarily mean unconflicted. I wonder about the internal identity of "jewishness" (let's call this habitus, per Bourdieu, and say it is complex, multifaceted, sensitive to suffering) and the external reality (field) of a militarily-dominant nation run by Jews.
I remember reading A Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood when I was in high school, and at that time in my life, I was anything but a pacifist in my mind. I thought about killing men (especially military men) all the time. Weird, huh? It's like I wanted to beat them at their own game - it's not enough to hate them for what they do to the world, you want to give them a taste of their own medicine. I suppose I don't feel so different today about Dick Cheney; I think that he deserves what he has done to the world. And yet ... and yet ... is it true? Would it destroy my own identity as - whatever I am - to inflict physical violence on another, or to wish it done? What are Jews doing to themselves in this perpetual war? How is their habitus changing? I think that humans can easily hold contradictory beliefs - "I am a pacifist," "I wish harm on another" - and yet, at a certain point, I also think that these contradictions manifest in decisions, in action. With the Jews, I wonder if some of the peacefulness of the culture, the cultured-ness of the culture hasn't died a little with the actions against Palestinians.
One of my favorite (?) stories of the holocaust was about the existential philosopher Viktor Frankl, who surviving the holocaust emerged with a theory about love and the inherent goodness of man. I heard about Nazi soldiers throwing his writings out in the snow, and he went out, barefoot, running around and collecting them. Another time, he was marching through the ice when he had this thought: "Then I grasped the meaning of the greatest secret that human poetry and human thought and belief have to impart: The salvation of man is through love and in love." How did he not want those Nazis to suffer as he had?
This is not to say that Viktor Frankl represents all Jews, but has Jewishness, in some way, survived through a culture of generosity and love in the face of hate, and has Jewishness diminished because of Israeli's institutionalized hatred and military might? Could the nation of Israel, in its pact with the military might of the Americans, be devouring some of the good of Jewishness? Or is it just another opportunity for individual agency to shine through the evil of particular structures? How can "good" individuals survive amidst the greater culture of military strength and material excess? This is, of course, not limited to Israel or to America or to any other country. Perhaps part of my problem is in conceptualizing countries as monolithic, when in fact they are structures upon structures, fields within fields, with agents running around and through them, combining them and separating them.
Another interesting thought, courtesy of my dad: when Bourdieu talks about trading symbolic capital for economic capital (as when a businessman buys a piece of art), he is actually talking about infusing the symbolic with economic capital. That is, the piece of art that is bought for $1 million is now worth $1 million. It is an investment, and because this symbol (this painting) now is worth this much, the businessman has commodified it (yay Marx!) and it is not just a symbol of his wealth and taste, it is an investment, a reservoir of economic capital.
Liberal Jews (probably excluding Israelis) acknowledge that the conquest of Israel/Palestine is an expression of symbolic capital: Jews are expressing their strength, mainly in military and wealth.
Interesting thought. I would think there are a number of Israelis who are liberal, and so probably recognize that 1) Israel/Palestine has been "conquered" and that 2) this is a show of strength. But it's an odd bind, isn't it, to be both socially liberal and to be supportive of a militant government? I guess that "socially-conscious" doesn't necessarily mean unconflicted. I wonder about the internal identity of "jewishness" (let's call this habitus, per Bourdieu, and say it is complex, multifaceted, sensitive to suffering) and the external reality (field) of a militarily-dominant nation run by Jews.
I remember reading A Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood when I was in high school, and at that time in my life, I was anything but a pacifist in my mind. I thought about killing men (especially military men) all the time. Weird, huh? It's like I wanted to beat them at their own game - it's not enough to hate them for what they do to the world, you want to give them a taste of their own medicine. I suppose I don't feel so different today about Dick Cheney; I think that he deserves what he has done to the world. And yet ... and yet ... is it true? Would it destroy my own identity as - whatever I am - to inflict physical violence on another, or to wish it done? What are Jews doing to themselves in this perpetual war? How is their habitus changing? I think that humans can easily hold contradictory beliefs - "I am a pacifist," "I wish harm on another" - and yet, at a certain point, I also think that these contradictions manifest in decisions, in action. With the Jews, I wonder if some of the peacefulness of the culture, the cultured-ness of the culture hasn't died a little with the actions against Palestinians.
One of my favorite (?) stories of the holocaust was about the existential philosopher Viktor Frankl, who surviving the holocaust emerged with a theory about love and the inherent goodness of man. I heard about Nazi soldiers throwing his writings out in the snow, and he went out, barefoot, running around and collecting them. Another time, he was marching through the ice when he had this thought: "Then I grasped the meaning of the greatest secret that human poetry and human thought and belief have to impart: The salvation of man is through love and in love." How did he not want those Nazis to suffer as he had?
This is not to say that Viktor Frankl represents all Jews, but has Jewishness, in some way, survived through a culture of generosity and love in the face of hate, and has Jewishness diminished because of Israeli's institutionalized hatred and military might? Could the nation of Israel, in its pact with the military might of the Americans, be devouring some of the good of Jewishness? Or is it just another opportunity for individual agency to shine through the evil of particular structures? How can "good" individuals survive amidst the greater culture of military strength and material excess? This is, of course, not limited to Israel or to America or to any other country. Perhaps part of my problem is in conceptualizing countries as monolithic, when in fact they are structures upon structures, fields within fields, with agents running around and through them, combining them and separating them.
Another interesting thought, courtesy of my dad: when Bourdieu talks about trading symbolic capital for economic capital (as when a businessman buys a piece of art), he is actually talking about infusing the symbolic with economic capital. That is, the piece of art that is bought for $1 million is now worth $1 million. It is an investment, and because this symbol (this painting) now is worth this much, the businessman has commodified it (yay Marx!) and it is not just a symbol of his wealth and taste, it is an investment, a reservoir of economic capital.
Sunday, December 21, 2008
The Little God in my skis
Today's church will be out in the snow, cross-country skiing with my parents and my dog. I am way too excited. Today, I got up and shoveled the driveway, which puts me in rarefied company here on Nina Lane. After shoveling, you get the privilege of talking about shoveling for the rest of the day ("ooh, it sure does hurt the wrists to shovel," "my, it's nice to have a shoveled driveway" and so on). Marvin is next to me, barking at the snow faeries, so we're excited to go out and find ourselves some trouble to get into.
I thought I'd comment to you, Lauren, about the "jewishness." I think that catholics have a similar thing; the "catholic identity." It's also why so many Americans claim to be Irish: the "otherness." I hated how O'Reilly liked to say that John Kerry wasn't really a catholic because he's pro-choice, as though catholic identity is some sort of checklist instead of a continuum, or even a grid of cultural and religious affiliation. This grid (four squares, top is high religious identity, bottom is low religious identity; right is high cultural identity, left is low cultural identity) is a useful conceit, but it also doesn't capture the very abstract notion of self-identification.
Anyhow, I think this is a peculiarly American ability - that of choosing your cultural affiliation. Perhaps because of the melting pot (or tossed salad, tee hee), we kind of cling to our otherness. As well, all Americans like to be "working class" or somehow slighted - it's our anti-elitism, and no American wants to be an elitist. So saying that your grandpa didn't go to college, or your great-grandma was from Romania, or whatever it is that makes you special and not elitist, you are salt of the earth. I remember Maureen Dowd suddenly claiming her blue collar status when Barack Obama was running against Hillary; Dowd pointed to some relative and somehow came out as blue collar. This was one week after she used opera as a metaphor. My point is that our disadvantaged creds are carried like medals, perhaps to remind others that we, too, "pulled ourselves up by our bootstraps." My dad's favorite joke, that Bush was born on third and thought he hit a triple, is probably true for most of us middle classers in today's America. We were born into unthinkable material privilege and comfort, but we're also of peasant stock. There is a tension. We're all so damn nouveau riche, treading unsteadily between gloating in our success and reminding ourselves that we're not far from failure.
Bourdieu claimed that we try and use certain forms of capital (say, economic) to trade for others (say, cultural). So a rich businessman will pay a (relatively) poor artist for a painting and both increase their capital - the businessman gets cultural capital, the artist gets economic capital. I think that, in Bourdieu's America, we seem to want to buy a folk capital. The French buy themselves class, the Americans buy themselves street cred.
Marvin is still getting upset at the snow faeries, so we'll go chase them down with my god-skis.
My, how the back does ache after a hard shoveling.
I thought I'd comment to you, Lauren, about the "jewishness." I think that catholics have a similar thing; the "catholic identity." It's also why so many Americans claim to be Irish: the "otherness." I hated how O'Reilly liked to say that John Kerry wasn't really a catholic because he's pro-choice, as though catholic identity is some sort of checklist instead of a continuum, or even a grid of cultural and religious affiliation. This grid (four squares, top is high religious identity, bottom is low religious identity; right is high cultural identity, left is low cultural identity) is a useful conceit, but it also doesn't capture the very abstract notion of self-identification.
Anyhow, I think this is a peculiarly American ability - that of choosing your cultural affiliation. Perhaps because of the melting pot (or tossed salad, tee hee), we kind of cling to our otherness. As well, all Americans like to be "working class" or somehow slighted - it's our anti-elitism, and no American wants to be an elitist. So saying that your grandpa didn't go to college, or your great-grandma was from Romania, or whatever it is that makes you special and not elitist, you are salt of the earth. I remember Maureen Dowd suddenly claiming her blue collar status when Barack Obama was running against Hillary; Dowd pointed to some relative and somehow came out as blue collar. This was one week after she used opera as a metaphor. My point is that our disadvantaged creds are carried like medals, perhaps to remind others that we, too, "pulled ourselves up by our bootstraps." My dad's favorite joke, that Bush was born on third and thought he hit a triple, is probably true for most of us middle classers in today's America. We were born into unthinkable material privilege and comfort, but we're also of peasant stock. There is a tension. We're all so damn nouveau riche, treading unsteadily between gloating in our success and reminding ourselves that we're not far from failure.
Bourdieu claimed that we try and use certain forms of capital (say, economic) to trade for others (say, cultural). So a rich businessman will pay a (relatively) poor artist for a painting and both increase their capital - the businessman gets cultural capital, the artist gets economic capital. I think that, in Bourdieu's America, we seem to want to buy a folk capital. The French buy themselves class, the Americans buy themselves street cred.
Marvin is still getting upset at the snow faeries, so we'll go chase them down with my god-skis.
My, how the back does ache after a hard shoveling.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)