This week I will be attending my father's 60th birthday, and so forgoing the weekly service. But Lauren and I attended something pretty spiritual today, and that is hot yoga, aka Bikram Yoga. I tried this a few years ago, but haven't been since. I do yoga on my own (or what I would prefer to call EK copyright yoga), and so I don't feel the need to pay someone to tell me what to do. But today was free yoga day, so Lauren and I ventured over to the temple of sweat.
We got there a little early, so I perused some of the information available, including an interview in Yoga Journal with Bikram Choudhury, the dude behind the phenomenon. He is spectacularly egotistical and, apparently, likes to sue people who teach yoga classes similar to his.
While I think the yoga is fine, it is boring and calculated, not at all organic. You hold every pose for a regimented amount of time, you only do certain poses, and you completely overwork certain muscle groups (shoulders, hamstrings) while ignoring others (biceps, abdominals). I love watching people's faces in the mirror as they struggle, and the incredibly hot, stuffy feeling that makes it seem like a real freaking accomplishment when you're done, covered in sweat and red-faced, hardly able to move. But the poses themselves? Eh. I like my yoga (EK copyright yoga, thank you very much) better.
What gets me more is the crass commercialism of the whole bizniz. I liked the yoga instructor, whose Sopranos-esque encouragement ("you can do dis, look at chou, that's just great") was a nice contrast to the usual mumbo-jumbo pseudo-spirituality that infuses most yoga classes. I liked a few of the poses, the instruction, the disregard for dimply thighs and stomach rolls exhibited by half-naked people all sweating together in a crowded room, but I still hate the whole idea of Bikram, copyrighted yoga.
Saturday, February 7, 2009
Monday, February 2, 2009
Enter, stage right, a man in a black robe with a gold vestment ...
As Lauren mentioned, the Orthodox service was pretty sparse, people-wise. We drove up to the old Lewisburg Grange Hall, a beautiful old building with wood paneling and heavy, creaky wood floors. It was a perfect setting for the seemingly frozen-in-time service that we were to experience. As soon as we entered the hall, this wonderful old woman named A greeted us. I think she was about to adopt us, she was so excited. We all (4 of us) chatted a bit, then we went up the stairs into the service (chapel?) room, which was a big, open, dimly-lit room with lots of candles and gold and red icons. My immediate thought was I love the decor. Followed by why are all these nice old women kissing things? I'll return to the kissing in a moment. We found out the priest (father?) was going to be 15 minutes late, so we went downstairs with A, who explained a bunch about Orthodoxy to us. The central point was that Orthodoxy is the "true" church (like I haven't heard that before!) but particularly that it has retained the true liturgy while everyone else, starting with the Catholics, have forsaken all of that. The liturgy, I guess, is part of their epic 6-hour weekly ritual that starts Saturday evening (which we attended) and continues Sunday morning. I'm not sure exactly what distinguishes the liturgy from the rest of it, but I can say that the 2+ hours we attended were virtually just the same things over and over. But I get ahead of myself. When we were downstairs with A, she showed us icons (again, I thought about how nice they would look in my living room). Finally, Father B arrived and our lady A joyously welcomed him; he was wearing a long black robe and said he'd spent the day "tubing" with the Orthodox kids. I wondered if he'd worn that black robe all day.
So the ceremony started. Father B came out in his black robe, but now with a gold robe over it, kind of Star Trek leader-like, with a big neck thing and a weird hat. He ritualistically blessed every icon, then every thing in the church, including my scarf, lying over on a bench (thank you). We were told that Orthodox people like to stand and do they ever: we didn't sit for the next two hours. Father B had a strong voice and would call out, quickly and magically, singing to the Lord. I thought that our presence was entirely superfluous at this ceremony: we were just watching this guy with OCD have a long ritual with his God. I mean, it was bizarre. And the singers (four of them?) sang along, sometimes repeating what the Father had said, sometimes just singing. And we would stand ... I kept looking at the old ladies in front of us, one of whom came up and told us, after about an hour, "that was Vespers and now is time for Psalms, and then we'll have [something else] and then we're done!" and I was thinking, Jesus, you must have thighs of steel. Because I was getting shin-splints from standing in one place for so long. Every once in a while, Father B would walk around the room and bless everything again, and we'd all slowly turn, always facing him as he made his way. Then he'd disappear behind the wall of icons at the front of the room, dim the lights, and change into another outfit. Gold, then black, then a different hat, then he'd reappear and start sing-chanting again, kissing icons, swinging his giant incense ball around. This is not a religion that favors interaction, it was more like we were the audience at a play and this guy got to do all the fun stuff. Another guy got to read every once in a while, and then the singers got to sing, but Lauren and I and the old ladies just stood around, feeling vaguely nauseated from all the incense smoke. Or that's just me. After about an hour and a half, I was truly excited to get to bow every once in a while, if only to relieve the building pain in my back from standing up.
Then the other congregants (all 5) went up to kiss some book and get blessed or something, but Lauren and I hung back. So this old lady looked at us and motioned for us to go up, which we did, very hesitantly. I went up to the Bible and just kind of bowed to it, as I felt that we weren't on kissing terms yet. Then I cupped my hands before the priest as I'd seen others do, and he put his hand in mine and I knew I was supposed to kiss it, but I felt uncomfortable, so I kind of made a kissing noise to the air and then moved away quickly.
Lauren and I left after 2 hours and 15 minutes, with "only about 20 minutes left" in the ceremony. And we were, of course, invited to the next day's service (9 to 12, followed by a potluck). I felt a little guilty because I know that this church is trying to establish itself in the U.S. and all that, but I think they need to change with the times a bit. Only old ladies with strong thighs and close relations with God can stand the service of the Orthodox.
So the ceremony started. Father B came out in his black robe, but now with a gold robe over it, kind of Star Trek leader-like, with a big neck thing and a weird hat. He ritualistically blessed every icon, then every thing in the church, including my scarf, lying over on a bench (thank you). We were told that Orthodox people like to stand and do they ever: we didn't sit for the next two hours. Father B had a strong voice and would call out, quickly and magically, singing to the Lord. I thought that our presence was entirely superfluous at this ceremony: we were just watching this guy with OCD have a long ritual with his God. I mean, it was bizarre. And the singers (four of them?) sang along, sometimes repeating what the Father had said, sometimes just singing. And we would stand ... I kept looking at the old ladies in front of us, one of whom came up and told us, after about an hour, "that was Vespers and now is time for Psalms, and then we'll have [something else] and then we're done!" and I was thinking, Jesus, you must have thighs of steel. Because I was getting shin-splints from standing in one place for so long. Every once in a while, Father B would walk around the room and bless everything again, and we'd all slowly turn, always facing him as he made his way. Then he'd disappear behind the wall of icons at the front of the room, dim the lights, and change into another outfit. Gold, then black, then a different hat, then he'd reappear and start sing-chanting again, kissing icons, swinging his giant incense ball around. This is not a religion that favors interaction, it was more like we were the audience at a play and this guy got to do all the fun stuff. Another guy got to read every once in a while, and then the singers got to sing, but Lauren and I and the old ladies just stood around, feeling vaguely nauseated from all the incense smoke. Or that's just me. After about an hour and a half, I was truly excited to get to bow every once in a while, if only to relieve the building pain in my back from standing up.
Then the other congregants (all 5) went up to kiss some book and get blessed or something, but Lauren and I hung back. So this old lady looked at us and motioned for us to go up, which we did, very hesitantly. I went up to the Bible and just kind of bowed to it, as I felt that we weren't on kissing terms yet. Then I cupped my hands before the priest as I'd seen others do, and he put his hand in mine and I knew I was supposed to kiss it, but I felt uncomfortable, so I kind of made a kissing noise to the air and then moved away quickly.
Lauren and I left after 2 hours and 15 minutes, with "only about 20 minutes left" in the ceremony. And we were, of course, invited to the next day's service (9 to 12, followed by a potluck). I felt a little guilty because I know that this church is trying to establish itself in the U.S. and all that, but I think they need to change with the times a bit. Only old ladies with strong thighs and close relations with God can stand the service of the Orthodox.
Sunday, February 1, 2009
5 + 2 = 7
Seven. That's right. That's the total number of Saturday night Orthodox mass attendees at the Lewisburg Grange Hall. And that's including me and Erin.
So, you guessed it... This week we attended the local Orthodox Church (as in the Orthodox that split away from the Catholics (depending on your historical account), not Jewish Orthodox). We walked into the Grange Hall and were immediately welcomed whole-heartedly by some of the congregants who were super excited to have visitors. We walked upstairs, and I was overpowered by the scent of incense. The room was elaborate and beautiful! I felt like I was transported to Turkey! The gold wall decorations, including many Jesus images, the Persian rugs, the stage altar with different Jesus/Theotokos (Mother Mary) images.... It was all so sureal that this church could exist just outside of Corvallis!
We spoke briefly with the "reader" (aka that dude with a very long beard who reads bible passages in tri-toned voice) and he gave us a pamphlet of what to expect. It didn't help. Experiencing it is the only way!!!!
In college, I studied religion. My senior seminar professor, was a Greek Orthodox Priest. As part of learning about religions, we had to do a brief phenonemology of an excerpt of the Divine Liturgy. This was my only experience relating to this religion beforehand. I remember being totally confused about what was happening everytime we watched the video for class. Experiencing it in person does not help at all. It was like watching a magic show! And you have to stand for 2 hours... So, here's what I saw: The whole mass is done a capella by a small group of singers and in English. The priest stands before the worshippers and does a whole lot of incensing many, many times. The worshippers cross themselves many, many times and follow each cross with a modified version of prostration. All women cover their heads. Once in a while the priest will sing/read from the text, but it is usually the tri-toned reader. The lights go on and off multiple times to evoke feelings related to the moment within the service. Some more incensing, lots and lots of singing. Two hours of this for the Saturday night mass, the start of the Sabbath, and it is still not finished!!! I thought I had it bad having to go to synagogue... Way worse! (Read any David Sedaris story on Greek Orthodox family members for more humorous accounts of following a different calendar year.)
The congregation was mostly older folks, mostly converts who were probably looking for a more intense religious experience. There was one small girl who was asleep half the time. I don't blame her. This is a dying religion, I think, which can probably be attributed to the fact that the service is so long! Why get God in 6 hours a week when you can go to a megachurch and get saved with only half an hour a week? I think that this shows not only the Orthodox inability to get with the times, but also our culture's lack of appreciation for all things slow (including but not limited to salvation). Mostly I think it's a shame because I love the elaborate gaudiness of the church. It's nice to know the church still got it!
So, you guessed it... This week we attended the local Orthodox Church (as in the Orthodox that split away from the Catholics (depending on your historical account), not Jewish Orthodox). We walked into the Grange Hall and were immediately welcomed whole-heartedly by some of the congregants who were super excited to have visitors. We walked upstairs, and I was overpowered by the scent of incense. The room was elaborate and beautiful! I felt like I was transported to Turkey! The gold wall decorations, including many Jesus images, the Persian rugs, the stage altar with different Jesus/Theotokos (Mother Mary) images.... It was all so sureal that this church could exist just outside of Corvallis!
We spoke briefly with the "reader" (aka that dude with a very long beard who reads bible passages in tri-toned voice) and he gave us a pamphlet of what to expect. It didn't help. Experiencing it is the only way!!!!
In college, I studied religion. My senior seminar professor, was a Greek Orthodox Priest. As part of learning about religions, we had to do a brief phenonemology of an excerpt of the Divine Liturgy. This was my only experience relating to this religion beforehand. I remember being totally confused about what was happening everytime we watched the video for class. Experiencing it in person does not help at all. It was like watching a magic show! And you have to stand for 2 hours... So, here's what I saw: The whole mass is done a capella by a small group of singers and in English. The priest stands before the worshippers and does a whole lot of incensing many, many times. The worshippers cross themselves many, many times and follow each cross with a modified version of prostration. All women cover their heads. Once in a while the priest will sing/read from the text, but it is usually the tri-toned reader. The lights go on and off multiple times to evoke feelings related to the moment within the service. Some more incensing, lots and lots of singing. Two hours of this for the Saturday night mass, the start of the Sabbath, and it is still not finished!!! I thought I had it bad having to go to synagogue... Way worse! (Read any David Sedaris story on Greek Orthodox family members for more humorous accounts of following a different calendar year.)
The congregation was mostly older folks, mostly converts who were probably looking for a more intense religious experience. There was one small girl who was asleep half the time. I don't blame her. This is a dying religion, I think, which can probably be attributed to the fact that the service is so long! Why get God in 6 hours a week when you can go to a megachurch and get saved with only half an hour a week? I think that this shows not only the Orthodox inability to get with the times, but also our culture's lack of appreciation for all things slow (including but not limited to salvation). Mostly I think it's a shame because I love the elaborate gaudiness of the church. It's nice to know the church still got it!
Monday, January 26, 2009
I can convert, if that makes things easier ...
So, Lauren may have mentioned Rabbi B, our holy man at Beit Am, the local Jewish ... uh, house. I mean, I guess it's a synagogue, but it's actually just a house. Lauren and I went into the living room, where we were greeted by a friendly woman who told me she was a convert, and were introduced to a couple of young women who turned out to be sophomores in college. I thought they were about twelve. Anyway, we were asked if we were students, we said yes. Then they asked if we were there for a world religions class - apparently, some class makes kids go to different churches/temples/mosques and all the churches/temples/mosques know about this. Do we look like a couple of undergrads taking a world religions class? Perhaps you can compare us to the barely pubescent girls standing next to us. So we said no, we're just visiting.
Anyway, we made ourselves comfortable as people filed in, a group of about 25, altogether. Several families, a couple of single women. Many people wore the little head caps (yarmulke or kippah), including most men and a few of the women. It was a cozy group, most people seemed familiar with each other, and all were very Corvallis looking. I mean, they wouldn't have been out of place at the Unitarian church - that kind of Corvallis. One older woman, when I asked if this was the only synagogue in the area, said that it was, but that they try very hard to be "inclusive" of different ways of expressing Jewish faith.
Then came Rabbi B. Oh, Rabbi. Well, for one thing, he likes to play guitar and sing in Hebrew. And I ask, who doesn't? It was a great time for all. I really perfected my weird middle eastern bleating. But Rabbi B has inspired me to look into conversion. For his sake. For my sake. For the sake of all of us. Alright, I'm not converting. I'd be more than embarassed if he ever were to stumble across this humble blog, but I guess he should know. He could make half this nation Jewish, if only he could get out there more often.
After the service, we talked to some nice people, including a woman and her very beautiful daughter who explained to me the 600+ rules of the extremely strict Jews. I asked if they followed the rules and the woman said "no, we religiously do not" and I thought that was a good answer. We ate some bread, drank a little wine, and milled about. Lauren had to explain over and over that yes, she's Jewish, but no, she hadn't been to temple in a number of years, and I got to say, excitedly, that this was my first temple experience since I was twelve, when the only Jewish kid in The Dalles had his Bar Mitzvah. I think it was less fun for Lauren (though I haven't read her blog entry yet), but I would rank the temple up there with the pentecostals for sheer good times. I loved the singing, the people were so friendly, and there was a real warmth to everything. Maybe because it all happened in a house, so it was like going to your weird uncle's place and finding out that all these people get together and sing and hey, why does that sign say you can't cook meat in this kitchen because it's for dairy? Well, I guess that's just because he's my weird uncle and, you know, he has a lot of rules he likes to follow.
I was a little put off by some of the reading selection on offer. There were a number of periodicals available that were zionist (okay) but also some that were pro-Israeli militancy. I have to think through my dislike of Israel right now. I would probably be called anti-Semitic by some because I really do have a hard time with Israel. Could a Jewish state coexist in the middle east without militancy?
Let's think a bit about Zionism. For a little Zionist context, go here: http://www.mideastweb.org/zionism.htm. A nice bit of history on the movement, along with early Israeli policies of discrimination, as well as forces (like anti-Semitism) pushing Jews toward Israel. I like the overtones of political ecology, as (for example) the kibbutz was created by early Jewish socialists to address the problem of preference for Arab labor among plantation owners. Or the associations among many Arabs between British imperialism and early Zionism.
One of the things that always gets me about Israeli apologetics is the notion that Arabs teach their children to hate Israelis. Alright, I can believe it. But what do Israelis teach their children? Can I be more critical of Israel because I link it to western imperialism, because it is a nation founded on imperialist ideals, not so different from my own nation? From the above website:
Well, Rabbi B, perhaps we can work through some of these issues in the decades to come.
XOXO,
EK
Anyway, we made ourselves comfortable as people filed in, a group of about 25, altogether. Several families, a couple of single women. Many people wore the little head caps (yarmulke or kippah), including most men and a few of the women. It was a cozy group, most people seemed familiar with each other, and all were very Corvallis looking. I mean, they wouldn't have been out of place at the Unitarian church - that kind of Corvallis. One older woman, when I asked if this was the only synagogue in the area, said that it was, but that they try very hard to be "inclusive" of different ways of expressing Jewish faith.
Then came Rabbi B. Oh, Rabbi. Well, for one thing, he likes to play guitar and sing in Hebrew. And I ask, who doesn't? It was a great time for all. I really perfected my weird middle eastern bleating. But Rabbi B has inspired me to look into conversion. For his sake. For my sake. For the sake of all of us. Alright, I'm not converting. I'd be more than embarassed if he ever were to stumble across this humble blog, but I guess he should know. He could make half this nation Jewish, if only he could get out there more often.
After the service, we talked to some nice people, including a woman and her very beautiful daughter who explained to me the 600+ rules of the extremely strict Jews. I asked if they followed the rules and the woman said "no, we religiously do not" and I thought that was a good answer. We ate some bread, drank a little wine, and milled about. Lauren had to explain over and over that yes, she's Jewish, but no, she hadn't been to temple in a number of years, and I got to say, excitedly, that this was my first temple experience since I was twelve, when the only Jewish kid in The Dalles had his Bar Mitzvah. I think it was less fun for Lauren (though I haven't read her blog entry yet), but I would rank the temple up there with the pentecostals for sheer good times. I loved the singing, the people were so friendly, and there was a real warmth to everything. Maybe because it all happened in a house, so it was like going to your weird uncle's place and finding out that all these people get together and sing and hey, why does that sign say you can't cook meat in this kitchen because it's for dairy? Well, I guess that's just because he's my weird uncle and, you know, he has a lot of rules he likes to follow.
I was a little put off by some of the reading selection on offer. There were a number of periodicals available that were zionist (okay) but also some that were pro-Israeli militancy. I have to think through my dislike of Israel right now. I would probably be called anti-Semitic by some because I really do have a hard time with Israel. Could a Jewish state coexist in the middle east without militancy?
Let's think a bit about Zionism. For a little Zionist context, go here: http://www.mideastweb.org/zionism.htm. A nice bit of history on the movement, along with early Israeli policies of discrimination, as well as forces (like anti-Semitism) pushing Jews toward Israel. I like the overtones of political ecology, as (for example) the kibbutz was created by early Jewish socialists to address the problem of preference for Arab labor among plantation owners. Or the associations among many Arabs between British imperialism and early Zionism.
One of the things that always gets me about Israeli apologetics is the notion that Arabs teach their children to hate Israelis. Alright, I can believe it. But what do Israelis teach their children? Can I be more critical of Israel because I link it to western imperialism, because it is a nation founded on imperialist ideals, not so different from my own nation? From the above website:
One of the earliest warnings about the Arab problem came from the Zionist writer Ahad Ha'am (Asher Ginsberg), who wrote in his 1891 essay "Truth from Eretz Israel" that in Palestine "it is hard to find tillable land that is not already tilled", and moreover:
- From abroad we are accustomed to believing that the Arabs are all desert savages, like donkeys, who neither see nor understand what goes on around them. But this is a big mistake... The Arabs, and especially those in the cities, understand our deeds and our desires in Eretz Israel, but they keep quiet and pretend not to understand, since they do not see our present activities as a threat to their future... However, if the time comes when the life of our people in Eretz Israel develops to the point of encroaching upon the native population, they will not easily yield their place.
Well, Rabbi B, perhaps we can work through some of these issues in the decades to come.
XOXO,
EK
Sunday, January 25, 2009
Just Jewin' it.
Friday night. The night of the Jewish sabbath. Erin and I started the evening in sin by a) going out to dinner, therefore requiring us to touch money, b) drinking cocktails, not manoschevitz wine, and c) eating meat and following it up with desserts that invariably had milk product in them. So it was a good start to our encounters with all 30 Jews in town.
I know Erin's going to pissed that I beat her to this comment, but the Rabbi was a total dreamboat and made temple totally worthwhile. I'll leave the rest open to Erin.
Now, this was possibly my first time going into a temple voluntarily in my entire life. It has been somewhere around a decade since the last time I looked at a Siddur, the Jewish prayer book. But memories came flooding back! It was strange remembering that at one point in time I used to be able to read Hebrew, instead of needing to rely on the transliteration like I did Friday night. Fortunately, we chose to go to the renewal service, which meant that all of the normal songs were sang with alternate tunes, and some new songs were added to the repetoire. What struck me most was everytime we started a new tune, the rabbi would encourage us to try it out using "yaidaidi" as our words. He said that this is a high form of prayer because you can focus not on the words, but on the meaning of the song within you. In other words, it's medatative. Interestingly enough I have memories of my grandmother signing similar tunes, using those non-words. I thought about how Jewish cultural memory is strong enough to transcend time and space- we all now the same songs and sing them with the same tunes, and even though it has been a long time since I've heard the Mourner's Kaddish, I can proudly say that I still know it. It's like wrinkles on your palm: you see them everyday and take them for granted. When you try to conjure up an image of these lines, you can't, but when you see them again, you know that they are all in order.
So, needless to say, it was an absolute trip for me to re-examine Judaism. It was also fun to be there with Erin, a goy. I was trying to explain to her what to expect before the service, but could only remember the important things during the service. For example, whatever you do, do not drop the siddur. If you do, you gotta kiss it. Do not, under any circumstances, take our your cell phone. Dear God, don't ring the doorbell!!! When they give you the wine, wait until we say the long-ass prayer!
Otherwise, the service was just as long as I remember them being. But the dreamy rabbi helped make it all easier to swallow.
I know Erin's going to pissed that I beat her to this comment, but the Rabbi was a total dreamboat and made temple totally worthwhile. I'll leave the rest open to Erin.
Now, this was possibly my first time going into a temple voluntarily in my entire life. It has been somewhere around a decade since the last time I looked at a Siddur, the Jewish prayer book. But memories came flooding back! It was strange remembering that at one point in time I used to be able to read Hebrew, instead of needing to rely on the transliteration like I did Friday night. Fortunately, we chose to go to the renewal service, which meant that all of the normal songs were sang with alternate tunes, and some new songs were added to the repetoire. What struck me most was everytime we started a new tune, the rabbi would encourage us to try it out using "yaidaidi" as our words. He said that this is a high form of prayer because you can focus not on the words, but on the meaning of the song within you. In other words, it's medatative. Interestingly enough I have memories of my grandmother signing similar tunes, using those non-words. I thought about how Jewish cultural memory is strong enough to transcend time and space- we all now the same songs and sing them with the same tunes, and even though it has been a long time since I've heard the Mourner's Kaddish, I can proudly say that I still know it. It's like wrinkles on your palm: you see them everyday and take them for granted. When you try to conjure up an image of these lines, you can't, but when you see them again, you know that they are all in order.
So, needless to say, it was an absolute trip for me to re-examine Judaism. It was also fun to be there with Erin, a goy. I was trying to explain to her what to expect before the service, but could only remember the important things during the service. For example, whatever you do, do not drop the siddur. If you do, you gotta kiss it. Do not, under any circumstances, take our your cell phone. Dear God, don't ring the doorbell!!! When they give you the wine, wait until we say the long-ass prayer!
Otherwise, the service was just as long as I remember them being. But the dreamy rabbi helped make it all easier to swallow.
Monday, January 12, 2009
You're a sheep and you know it
Lauren recounted how we decided to go to a Jehovah's Witness service and how we were miraculously visited by N, our JW. N was, indeed, awkward, though not nearly as awkward as G, his friend. G just kind of looked at us when introduced and his handshake epitomized the "dead fish."
The service was mind-numbing. Lauren and I sat in the back and warbled our way through the first song. A nice, overweight woman in front of us (Lauren is right - JW girls are BBW) loaned us her song book, and all the song lyrics are pulled directly from the bible. My brain went into cruise control and I occupied myself by reading little snippets from the old testament about weird tests that God thought he needed to put people through, back when God had a very different relationship with humans (apparently).
The first speaker, who gave a 30-minute sermon, was a kind of funny old man with unfortunate hair. He got up and started talking about the world being like a chess game because we've got a king and then we've got these rooks and zzzzzzzzz ... sorry, I dozed off there for a second. Um, I think he was saying that Christ was the king but it was all backwards because the king died to save the pawns. He seemed to think it was a big deal that the game is similar to human society, as though the game and human society are of two separate realms.
Back to the JW obsession with the Bible. I was listening to this radio program last night on NPR and the guest talked about an era before Jews had a coherent view of the afterlife. Isn't it amazing that our faith is so young? Elaine Pagels has a book about Satan and how he's a recent invention, too. By "recent" I mean within the last couple of millenia, but still: our religious system has grown with our modern world. Back to the JWs: I guess I have a hard time with such reliance on the Bible when the Bible is so reflective of particular times, changing with what we need within society. It is a living book, I believe that; it is living because nothing in human society can be entombed as truth. No matter how hard we try to point to eternal truths, change is the only constant. Of course, the collected books that we have in today's Bible were pretty much settled on by (what? Nicene Council-ish? About 300 AD?) - but does that mean they haven't changed since then? I don't mean through translations, I mean that the actual content is read differently.
This is one of the fundamental truths, I guess, that I believe in: you can't stop time, and you can't decide that something is right and everything else is wrong, full speed ahead, damn all evidence to the contrary. Your belief system crumbles in the face of dissonance. And then you have to come up with new explanations, new tricks to incorporate new evidence (dinosaurs lived with humans! The grand canyon was created in the flood!), when you're really ignoring the evidence and covering your ears and shutting your eyes and screaming out "LA LA LA LA I don't hear you!" I guess this is me, child of the post-enlightenment, product of my times.
I had this big argument years ago with my friend M, about whether science was just another religion. Maybe it is. At the time, my position was that science and religion are very different, but I think I've come around to a different point of view. Science is a religion of tangible evidence. Its fetishes are calculability, prediction. I think it is wrong to point to "Darwinism" or something of that ilk and say that it's just dogma; dogma is not part of the scientific epistemology. The substance of religion is weird, but so is the substance of science; what distinguishes them is how they decide what is "real" in the world. What makes religion different from science is how knowledge is gathered - whether it is from above (over time, handed down by elders) or below (new is better, building on the past but always changing). But science is not SO different from religion, because we've seen that religion continues to change, too, to fit new information with old beliefs in ways that make sense. And, besides, I think that science, too, will be found wanting. I guess this is where postmodernists come in, and my own discomfort with what I view as overreliance on positivism within the sciences.
The point of the NPR program last night was that doubters have a role in history that is often overlooked. Our society may be overly fond of change - especially since change is commercialized, enshrined in our market system - but at least we're not just worshipping at the altar of Zeus. So I think I'm saying that Christianity might have arisen from doubt, too. Christians doubted something about the old testament, and Christianity has, in its DNA, the logic of doubt. I guess that's why we have about a million Christian sects, and they're all pretty sure of their truthiness, but they all claim to stick to the Bible. Yet another bit of evidence for my theory that the Bible is a living book (thank you, science!).
If my head explodes soon, I have only myself to thank.
The service was mind-numbing. Lauren and I sat in the back and warbled our way through the first song. A nice, overweight woman in front of us (Lauren is right - JW girls are BBW) loaned us her song book, and all the song lyrics are pulled directly from the bible. My brain went into cruise control and I occupied myself by reading little snippets from the old testament about weird tests that God thought he needed to put people through, back when God had a very different relationship with humans (apparently).
The first speaker, who gave a 30-minute sermon, was a kind of funny old man with unfortunate hair. He got up and started talking about the world being like a chess game because we've got a king and then we've got these rooks and zzzzzzzzz ... sorry, I dozed off there for a second. Um, I think he was saying that Christ was the king but it was all backwards because the king died to save the pawns. He seemed to think it was a big deal that the game is similar to human society, as though the game and human society are of two separate realms.
Back to the JW obsession with the Bible. I was listening to this radio program last night on NPR and the guest talked about an era before Jews had a coherent view of the afterlife. Isn't it amazing that our faith is so young? Elaine Pagels has a book about Satan and how he's a recent invention, too. By "recent" I mean within the last couple of millenia, but still: our religious system has grown with our modern world. Back to the JWs: I guess I have a hard time with such reliance on the Bible when the Bible is so reflective of particular times, changing with what we need within society. It is a living book, I believe that; it is living because nothing in human society can be entombed as truth. No matter how hard we try to point to eternal truths, change is the only constant. Of course, the collected books that we have in today's Bible were pretty much settled on by (what? Nicene Council-ish? About 300 AD?) - but does that mean they haven't changed since then? I don't mean through translations, I mean that the actual content is read differently.
This is one of the fundamental truths, I guess, that I believe in: you can't stop time, and you can't decide that something is right and everything else is wrong, full speed ahead, damn all evidence to the contrary. Your belief system crumbles in the face of dissonance. And then you have to come up with new explanations, new tricks to incorporate new evidence (dinosaurs lived with humans! The grand canyon was created in the flood!), when you're really ignoring the evidence and covering your ears and shutting your eyes and screaming out "LA LA LA LA I don't hear you!" I guess this is me, child of the post-enlightenment, product of my times.
I had this big argument years ago with my friend M, about whether science was just another religion. Maybe it is. At the time, my position was that science and religion are very different, but I think I've come around to a different point of view. Science is a religion of tangible evidence. Its fetishes are calculability, prediction. I think it is wrong to point to "Darwinism" or something of that ilk and say that it's just dogma; dogma is not part of the scientific epistemology. The substance of religion is weird, but so is the substance of science; what distinguishes them is how they decide what is "real" in the world. What makes religion different from science is how knowledge is gathered - whether it is from above (over time, handed down by elders) or below (new is better, building on the past but always changing). But science is not SO different from religion, because we've seen that religion continues to change, too, to fit new information with old beliefs in ways that make sense. And, besides, I think that science, too, will be found wanting. I guess this is where postmodernists come in, and my own discomfort with what I view as overreliance on positivism within the sciences.
The point of the NPR program last night was that doubters have a role in history that is often overlooked. Our society may be overly fond of change - especially since change is commercialized, enshrined in our market system - but at least we're not just worshipping at the altar of Zeus. So I think I'm saying that Christianity might have arisen from doubt, too. Christians doubted something about the old testament, and Christianity has, in its DNA, the logic of doubt. I guess that's why we have about a million Christian sects, and they're all pretty sure of their truthiness, but they all claim to stick to the Bible. Yet another bit of evidence for my theory that the Bible is a living book (thank you, science!).
If my head explodes soon, I have only myself to thank.
Sunday, January 11, 2009
Can I get a witness?
Here goes this weekends accounts on religion:
Friday
EK: Lauren, what church should we go to?
Me: I don't know. Where do you want to go?
EK: How about the Jehovah's Witnesses?
Me: Yeah. That sounds good.
Saturday
A knock on our door. EK answers and chats to a strange visitor. Post coversation,
Me: Who was that?
EK: A Jehovah's Witness. It was his easiest sell.
Moral of the story, God wanted us to visit with the Jehovah's Witnesses today.
We entered the senior center (where they are temporarily holding services) and were approached by two very awkward men, including our Saturday visitor. They tried to find seats for us, and upon the suggestion that we sit in the front, I suggested we set up seats at the back of the room. Mostly for an easy escape route, especially after they told us we would do a bible study for over an hour. Argh.
My first impressions of the service were mostly that I felt like this reminds me of the movie Jesus Camp. It brought a whole new light to the term "Bible Thumpers." Every thought from the sermon was supported by a passage from the bible. This was my first time taking such a close look at the bible, but it was a quick tour through, as we were constantly turning pages, trying to figure out where, exactly, the Book of Matthew might be found. Before or after Exodus?
The population was also interesting to observe. Couples pray arm in arm. Almost all of the women were extremely overweight. Weirdest of all, all the men had these black suitcases that they kept handy. They must have all of their sell material in there. Or something?
Some things I learned about the JW's:
1) They LOVE the image of Jesus being a shepard. They love the image of us being sheep needing guidance. Do not stray.
2) There are a lot of options for sex/sexual curiosity/sexual gratification. All but one are wrong: sex in marriage RULES! Do not stray, fine young sheep. Don't be tempted by TV, movies, or things you happen upon while on the interwebs.
3) The devil will slap you. That's right. Avoid the slap from satan. Is that actually code for masturbation? All I know is that I almost died of laughter with the image of satan slapping me.
4) Jehovah's Witness men are awkward.
5) Our witness will probably come back to our house over and over again, until, as he said, it's like having tea with a friend. NOO!!!!!!
Friday
EK: Lauren, what church should we go to?
Me: I don't know. Where do you want to go?
EK: How about the Jehovah's Witnesses?
Me: Yeah. That sounds good.
Saturday
A knock on our door. EK answers and chats to a strange visitor. Post coversation,
Me: Who was that?
EK: A Jehovah's Witness. It was his easiest sell.
Moral of the story, God wanted us to visit with the Jehovah's Witnesses today.
We entered the senior center (where they are temporarily holding services) and were approached by two very awkward men, including our Saturday visitor. They tried to find seats for us, and upon the suggestion that we sit in the front, I suggested we set up seats at the back of the room. Mostly for an easy escape route, especially after they told us we would do a bible study for over an hour. Argh.
My first impressions of the service were mostly that I felt like this reminds me of the movie Jesus Camp. It brought a whole new light to the term "Bible Thumpers." Every thought from the sermon was supported by a passage from the bible. This was my first time taking such a close look at the bible, but it was a quick tour through, as we were constantly turning pages, trying to figure out where, exactly, the Book of Matthew might be found. Before or after Exodus?
The population was also interesting to observe. Couples pray arm in arm. Almost all of the women were extremely overweight. Weirdest of all, all the men had these black suitcases that they kept handy. They must have all of their sell material in there. Or something?
Some things I learned about the JW's:
1) They LOVE the image of Jesus being a shepard. They love the image of us being sheep needing guidance. Do not stray.
2) There are a lot of options for sex/sexual curiosity/sexual gratification. All but one are wrong: sex in marriage RULES! Do not stray, fine young sheep. Don't be tempted by TV, movies, or things you happen upon while on the interwebs.
3) The devil will slap you. That's right. Avoid the slap from satan. Is that actually code for masturbation? All I know is that I almost died of laughter with the image of satan slapping me.
4) Jehovah's Witness men are awkward.
5) Our witness will probably come back to our house over and over again, until, as he said, it's like having tea with a friend. NOO!!!!!!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)